{
  "description": "Host acceptance scenarios (SPEC 6, 7, 8.3, 8.4, 9.1). Each scenario is one host's view of one repository: create a rules engine for `hostKey` (a.vault.example) with head bound `headBound`, apply `steps` in order, and each step's verdict MUST equal `expect` (\"ok\" or the SPEC 10.4 code). Then the accepted commits with no accepted child MUST be exactly `finalHeads`, the held commits (SPEC 6.5) exactly `finalHeld`, and the winning chain's tip manifestHash `finalTip` (null when no state was accepted). When a scenario has `finalLeaves`, the pending leave requests (SPEC 8.4, one per member) MUST be exactly those `{ memberKey, at }`. A stored commit whose removal cutoff cannot yet be decided (SPEC 7.3) is neither a head nor held. Steps: `op` is manifest, commit, or leave. A manifest step's `item` is `{ manifest: SignedManifest, commit?: Commit }`, the publishManifest body: the commit is the genesis commit (createRepo), the rotation commit of an epoch-raising state, or absent; the state and its commit are applied together or not at all (SPEC 8.2, 8.3). A commit step's `item` is a Commit; a leave step's `item` is a LeaveRequest. `via` is the path: \"push\" is a client write (push, createRepo, publishManifest, leave) whose authenticated caller is the commit author, the owner for a manifest, or memberKey for a leave, with the head bound applied; \"offer\" is replication from a peer host (SPEC 9.1): no caller check and no head bound. A held commit answers forbidden on either path. `label` names the item for reading only. Every expectation is written by hand from the SPEC rule each description cites. Keys, hosts, data keys, and wraps are those of manifest.json, plus an epoch 2 data key (32 bytes of 0x44) used only by content-epoch-jump-2; each commit's payload is {\"v\":2,\"accounts\":{}} under AAD v2 with IV SHA-256(UTF8(\"avp/vectors/acceptance-iv/\" + label))[0..12]. Where two diverged states must hash in a set order, the losing one's wraps use the label \"<member>/g<i>\" for the first i that puts its manifestHash above the winner's. Generated by vectors/generate.ts.",
  "scenarios": [
    {
      "name": "genesis-ok",
      "description": "SPEC 6.2, 8.2: a valid genesis state that lists this host, published with a first commit that has no parents, cites seq 1 and the genesis hash, is by the owner at epoch 0: both are accepted and the commit is the only head.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "genesis-wrong-repo-id",
      "description": "SPEC 6.2, 4.2: the genesis repoId does not recompute from ownerKey and genesisNonce (it was derived from another nonce), so the state is rejected (bad_request) and its commit with it.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G-wrong-repo-id + r-wrong-repo",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "ndV4hcP0XHhIOjCt8XXhrg",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "OzIrCYu/+wQz6L2B1riEO0M1MoE9QlWpXXV0iDfxEU3HDSQafgNTA00WiJEdl3P/nxXjW11h3kZIeNnsv2elAg=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "ndV4hcP0XHhIOjCt8XXhrg",
              "commitId": "WMco+yYBBK9yTKFj4B5amAfGo1Dl8tEz8eBjV4Rini8=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "cfPgbDk64RQAXrCfq0voacsEvF4hxYXsR+BCGxaBNQk=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "sWTVX0jNAZ5E1Wap",
              "ciphertext": "y32EYBY74kKVznYUmg3QD6BQFk27fh1gL0EJclwXR6CJco1UfQ==",
              "authorSignature": "dXsIMmYx88R8iFQypCTmkU/Tw2sUJrfbINYDtfHPeh88nRewj+pUmXrwgC1EaeYC6EJ0+SuiOY7JMvg/iw0aDg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": null
    },
    {
      "name": "genesis-host-not-listed",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 6, 8.2: a valid genesis whose hosts list only b.vault.example, applied at a.vault.example: not_hosted, nothing stored.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G-hosts-b-only + r-b",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "gCQwT0LLSl49JkcR7rXsdNbdkwmMlwov0561fMIsAJKAFpsJ8CU/EeTsmwvUzZ/wRFqhCJMswM7rejU8UkaTCA=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "jn/60Ax+yq1ovtmyLLwnwmTNfbQ917xrElRPBhm0zT8=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "ziM5Qj/BgOrpKo1LEFldup1uro1yK9RPmqgbNlB69W4=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "/TvDEkzBYzptuEow",
              "ciphertext": "CVduPSOBlgFrMpbnazku6g9ZZghBe+lz2fOgvCPXqfcd7dCazA==",
              "authorSignature": "IzzVuofYF0SzgaBiNyQ5P8LyF37oyBhKf6AyhRuekL2ohLVT4Hz6pBZCbfHghWnx3xvCuQizxbOGQlZdmvYGAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "not_hosted"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": null
    },
    {
      "name": "manifest-seq-skip",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 4, 6.3: a seq 3 state arrives while the tip is seq 1 (its seq 2 predecessor never arrived); its seq is not tip + 1, so manifest_conflict.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "WQjCaHUMnHNVwNRArL9hlYjDQVHoEin5s9ualFgL05bHkHqm024yjl7rm7nAkybsDW63oHDeFV43a9a2U1oFDw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "manifest_conflict"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "manifest-bad-owner-sig",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 2: a seq 2 state whose ownerSignature is alice's signature, not the owner's: bad_request; the tip stays at genesis.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-signed-by-alice",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "KelHHaxVUnoH5ow455fdlMb5vTU3HbJKjgVrH/K0wpbVoOpYdyOa9OfUZA2EUhThyYg9RtGou2kaag9yWtQGBw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "manifest-rollback",
      "description": "SPEC 6.3, 6.4, 12.3: after seq 2 and seq 3 are accepted, the seq 2 state is published again; its seq is not tip + 1, so manifest_conflict, and the tip stays at seq 3.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "WQjCaHUMnHNVwNRArL9hlYjDQVHoEin5s9ualFgL05bHkHqm024yjl7rm7nAkybsDW63oHDeFV43a9a2U1oFDw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-again",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "manifest_conflict"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "jEdpcSwFG4kEEtLdDVvG+lScCHXSAc0OplZ9bLndZbE="
    },
    {
      "name": "manifest-member-dropped-without-removal",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: a seq 3 state drops bob from members without a removal: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3-drops-bob",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "NFtmdiAbANmq6blbHsU6IPMtkwZWh7rmCKr7EuHvO6HSNJ48BPtGbe3E/TpiHQqrqRvsw3t0WqpzPffaTt+oAQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0="
    },
    {
      "name": "manifest-removal-without-epoch-bump",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: a seq 3 state adds a removal but keeps keyEpoch 0; a state that adds a removal MUST raise keyEpoch by one: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3-removal-epoch-0",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "attEQ7CTSrHIh1ZchEnZToEi5/SrPXWUVvqB6hAM9J/LRl58F6dz0CH+C7hYqxcc4S2zD8NN6a9rKyBdA1NkCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0="
    },
    {
      "name": "commit-non-member",
      "description": "SPEC 7.1, 7.2: carol, who is not a member, commits under genesis: forbidden on push (the caller is not a member of the tip) and forbidden by replication (the author is not a member of the cited state).",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "c1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "U2eQjJW3xlj5y7vh+yb6dSp/bHuW6nFH8M+7GwYpn14=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 1,
            "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "iv": "D5G3CEzbFUMQyAQs",
            "ciphertext": "LD44e/CMc6e9G3oWYpUT6hu1qyxXb5rbZMOmcrY8BR2ecICx+Q==",
            "authorSignature": "W45BrbldS3oBM4HZkgeKshFlrF9s7XKVH6slwgv/R4wCSraq0R2HB/WYUd0reRArEgPPcmwAXYW0Pf6ffYUiDQ=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "c1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "U2eQjJW3xlj5y7vh+yb6dSp/bHuW6nFH8M+7GwYpn14=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 1,
            "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "iv": "D5G3CEzbFUMQyAQs",
            "ciphertext": "LD44e/CMc6e9G3oWYpUT6hu1qyxXb5rbZMOmcrY8BR2ecICx+Q==",
            "authorSignature": "W45BrbldS3oBM4HZkgeKshFlrF9s7XKVH6slwgv/R4wCSraq0R2HB/WYUd0reRArEgPPcmwAXYW0Pf6ffYUiDQ=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "commit-epoch-mismatch",
      "description": "SPEC 7.2: alice cites seq 2 (keyEpoch 0) but writes keyEpoch 1: forbidden.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-epoch-1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Z4LuUzErT1QRHfKHRbMs+YUGIFDSv+g4EafkmMLyeZM=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 1,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "j9tcq7HXZsUMbtrS",
            "ciphertext": "HFpMYkPhXvWHqhSWVSxmHrwt4hMfFHe+SNBlDreglLx9DyCHHQ==",
            "authorSignature": "ZiDfe18TN0u+HvHrd+4EhZUISaJRuu3vzYs+rfk/YY9YvZrn47AeSiar78J4jyZY+1KFPRlBtLCik2j07EyhDA=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "commit-unknown-parent",
      "description": "SPEC 7.4: a1's parent a0 is unknown: missing_parents, which is retryable; once a0 is accepted the same a1 is accepted.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Hy6nJMQZEGMuGovvwWP8F+iozdhti5wBZr7pP5K4VCI=",
            "parents": [
              "7mOlwqQz6eY9HHSSNms6x/f7hri6wP+AYqhudnSH7Gs="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWH/wRkHcP4OvEk+7Qfcsw9w==",
            "authorSignature": "Ao0g4j6mWPsKIZy2bWVnKdHcr0sB2oglGaGq2iauF9kxICXlsSxTgGanCydglEzWYDkO0+imQqFGlWUcLnIMBA=="
          },
          "expect": "missing_parents"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a0",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "7mOlwqQz6eY9HHSSNms6x/f7hri6wP+AYqhudnSH7Gs=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "ctmgFbuYBS559B10",
            "ciphertext": "2BbzMNtStOF6oXEP3hNM+zwYi1Kc7wyvhClULr9rt9YVRmb2wQ==",
            "authorSignature": "iKHAr+RbM2bmpNYuMjI1Sx+LjcFx5gLsDetnyPS5Q7/nZeH5zGMSErDxHDN3oG8TucMNGiOxFddAsZXPjQM4BQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Hy6nJMQZEGMuGovvwWP8F+iozdhti5wBZr7pP5K4VCI=",
            "parents": [
              "7mOlwqQz6eY9HHSSNms6x/f7hri6wP+AYqhudnSH7Gs="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWH/wRkHcP4OvEk+7Qfcsw9w==",
            "authorSignature": "Ao0g4j6mWPsKIZy2bWVnKdHcr0sB2oglGaGq2iauF9kxICXlsSxTgGanCydglEzWYDkO0+imQqFGlWUcLnIMBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "Hy6nJMQZEGMuGovvwWP8F+iozdhti5wBZr7pP5K4VCI="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "commit-unknown-manifest",
      "description": "SPEC 7.2 manifest binding: a commit citing a validly signed state this host never received gets missing_parents; so does one citing seq 3 with the seq 2 manifestHash, since the pair names no held state.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-cites-unknown-state",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "IgoWddFSCI7DJPc3y/2GRwwilJOy52FkY++xyQvyHBI=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "t+G0jHYWUf7kAp4HcUGAtW2dJIIspOdnjIsgov6VSA8=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "9j+OW6xJBjOdYaQp",
            "ciphertext": "TLYQ4oPc2t5xX6eqVqjRAfpfch4fZvOgb5YsOxFRwoabVEsdAw==",
            "authorSignature": "VvDVfnzUPwupRrA7fOKwhUo/hxzXTtGvY289lqDRtoEmd4qcKLC/ZOWA6D4wkIIigF5fiqD96ALRjJUeRxMDBg=="
          },
          "expect": "missing_parents"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a2-seq-hash-mismatch",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "rS9G8dSmGyJaEP5omyxOJI4OdHlbE3DtWrykkXjUs28=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "27bp1hmrfL10nCqW",
            "ciphertext": "p0Q9UcJsFLCSsTTXsk0YQDUeWkOSQI550ITlNI8Ek+oMBBFH7w==",
            "authorSignature": "6IGzE+7GAiZfeEB+AYz0RBLwfxvis7uVeC0YAHI9quaWju71Slh8HVS6fD66BKKP09MzKgv/5VaV33yjFoLbCg=="
          },
          "expect": "missing_parents"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "commit-id-mismatch",
      "description": "SPEC 7.1: a1 with one ciphertext byte flipped but its commitId and signature kept: the id does not recompute, bad_request; the untampered a1 is then accepted.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-tampered-ciphertext",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "y+5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "jlrY7XR71fm7hGRvbFttoQGC5YITXLMlTDQZYTmt8QLYvhynpVAsv2mEnUo4DtpbxoPX5Bjzforjvrwb+e1rBA=="
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "jlrY7XR71fm7hGRvbFttoQGC5YITXLMlTDQZYTmt8QLYvhynpVAsv2mEnUo4DtpbxoPX5Bjzforjvrwb+e1rBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "commit-bad-author-signature",
      "description": "SPEC 7.1: a1 whose authorSignature is bob's signature over a1's id: it does not verify under the author (alice), bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-signed-by-bob",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "nKqvLHtfNp58kd0vyCjRVYabMsM7qyWxaQkMIaygi3Ur/FEJcIaY4zR0lcdgd/NLtmJyz3nVmlO+7NjIELVZAA=="
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "commit-wrong-repo-id",
      "description": "SPEC 7.1: a commit whose repoId is another repository's: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-other-repo",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "ndV4hcP0XHhIOjCt8XXhrg",
            "commitId": "TKbDfCcuGJ+l/hBadxfJswws5BKGqZkbhUQM/xt4SIM=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "OraAcxvrWDRe7jz9",
            "ciphertext": "Xt33Fu0gJhEQ/xFYV19M4myxo2cxyZjVywUEzOXXjKyhNh+0HQ==",
            "authorSignature": "J3//xwep6uiMNTrkxxgwQhOhLvKQVhHQg++yN9zLHuwerkTNpiAGo44seeHb7l7PJT+Z/qosW879nbeEizSWDg=="
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "commit-repush-idempotent",
      "description": "SPEC 7, 12.3: a commit the host already holds is accepted again with no change, by push and by replication.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "jlrY7XR71fm7hGRvbFttoQGC5YITXLMlTDQZYTmt8QLYvhynpVAsv2mEnUo4DtpbxoPX5Bjzforjvrwb+e1rBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "jlrY7XR71fm7hGRvbFttoQGC5YITXLMlTDQZYTmt8QLYvhynpVAsv2mEnUo4DtpbxoPX5Bjzforjvrwb+e1rBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "jlrY7XR71fm7hGRvbFttoQGC5YITXLMlTDQZYTmt8QLYvhynpVAsv2mEnUo4DtpbxoPX5Bjzforjvrwb+e1rBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "commit-citing-older-state-ok",
      "description": "SPEC 7.2: after seq 3 adds bob, alice's commit citing seq 2 (where she is a member at epoch 0) is still valid.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "WQjCaHUMnHNVwNRArL9hlYjDQVHoEin5s9ualFgL05bHkHqm024yjl7rm7nAkybsDW63oHDeFV43a9a2U1oFDw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-cites-seq-2",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "LG1FAQ/Y7qYtaKjEz9JGQpJWRDKel4cpnqyw5mnLQkM=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "R0BlRRvFM2c3vusV",
            "ciphertext": "YOsUw+0G8PYUPsefogHtG/z17F1BwEhLPRCXD+RC5gLe8i5rOQ==",
            "authorSignature": "rUUrssOOXeuykHPfwmvdOkEgmiQ62J5yEr32Q3uZTzpjJy/P70xwsxYq7vg70PqwUo80eViuVQjwO8h9iRt0Bw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "LG1FAQ/Y7qYtaKjEz9JGQpJWRDKel4cpnqyw5mnLQkM="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "jEdpcSwFG4kEEtLdDVvG+lScCHXSAc0OplZ9bLndZbE="
    },
    {
      "name": "concurrent-commits-two-heads",
      "description": "SPEC 7.4: alice and bob each write a child of the root; both are accepted and both are heads.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "NBKmJpxb1+aVBlmZ+w9zfRzrifgxeTPFs8FYr54VTZr+5ofVcIUStwyeCJ1c2HrmPjLBWDLHK3TiyW60t6nYAg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "ja7DPQSFiSKcH8/P",
            "ciphertext": "LCwZLe1snwQHUL00n9nTotPVnv4uv5wI4NrxeswHPKDMlBSTqg==",
            "authorSignature": "ZSzcMthK/wLlICIQskYQusscst9+emsKrMGQtg6SFhBPMkap5ud1e33eyDzSNLmxT05LhbNSK4n38wgJrUobCg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
        "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0="
    },
    {
      "name": "merge-collapses-heads",
      "description": "SPEC 7.4, 5: a merge commit naming both heads as parents is accepted and becomes the only head.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "NBKmJpxb1+aVBlmZ+w9zfRzrifgxeTPFs8FYr54VTZr+5ofVcIUStwyeCJ1c2HrmPjLBWDLHK3TiyW60t6nYAg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "ja7DPQSFiSKcH8/P",
            "ciphertext": "LCwZLe1snwQHUL00n9nTotPVnv4uv5wI4NrxeswHPKDMlBSTqg==",
            "authorSignature": "ZSzcMthK/wLlICIQskYQusscst9+emsKrMGQtg6SFhBPMkap5ud1e33eyDzSNLmxT05LhbNSK4n38wgJrUobCg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "merge",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "GFht8cdBgI3I1dGW1w0gmCXMre+7asBeAfOMacliiHE=",
            "parents": [
              "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
              "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "zUoFNxx5wRPTQe1R",
            "ciphertext": "5Y6MbrnVzkhAgp3ELAwA/++ehjLau3k2ZdabPVy7aAX2jCmDVg==",
            "authorSignature": "/46b3fbd7uQ34gxIh7Cu1XHF5imxoX4n5hu53pBckYuAy2Z3Vl7VqZgvDVms2epxrLocnKcEA93p0uJYhRP0Cw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "GFht8cdBgI3I1dGW1w0gmCXMre+7asBeAfOMacliiHE="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0="
    },
    {
      "name": "merge-at-head-bound",
      "description": "SPEC 7.4: sixteen children of the root give sixteen heads (the sixteenth push leaves exactly the bound, which is allowed); a merge of two of them would leave 16 - 2 + 1 = 15 heads and MUST be accepted at the bound.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "uMdS8LxsENhtT7ydxUHbd/1QXe9KP87a1969elNZcPg=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "uDS6XJj3GI/uNeEd",
            "ciphertext": "Enubp9K/EQtkQL8uRMzCv19liqONlxWIt/LRXzh+xsjTgSGvfg==",
            "authorSignature": "a0wAAxB+n94eo44XkwEVzOmd/jC/hL5RHt+SfiLTsSR5NFVX2L1QFGF7FHz9RJeqaVUgY/S78LBpo7AZoSSwDg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-2",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "cs/uOeh+vpuOJ1EnQTSe2E2ILsNabMfKdf/CXy3Z9Iw=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "K4YaHfoZu6OrWEiX",
            "ciphertext": "dFEZJpxovT2M/QQpjXt7uf0X4mE5nM3TR3esxCwUMfw4MwwRlA==",
            "authorSignature": "jxSzm2Kwh0nRNcSfM3Ay0uJF5jrYrpLyN5Ep1TX9iGN2f89s/eNyeXzZcWLFVO+AUXU2c+0lkYGQghOYt/9cDQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "8qa4eEPTozV5/+bk0gyXcYkUvPsFmzmD/IqPe5E+/bY=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "MXnxk02Yvb/ntbWO",
            "ciphertext": "YOAZ7oymqf3m5dWlPqGLZhKzemRiwHOyJUfrsDI+rti5mkHtKQ==",
            "authorSignature": "rOyqny98xUxkHvRPEklHukBLS6BZrxmf9w3d4EC9J6rdm244ZiufP0PJE1ugiZ3ulxbtF7H1iaD9K0lcblvGBw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-4",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "3zNwgv6w8tVx2YhsfsToomblZJ+Z9xpaasKO2VhsT18=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "PbdsysYC2OVrj3o8",
            "ciphertext": "+On33lAVkp0L1Ti2OQtN+616R+HlBYHSG4xe2iWZdCXj1DdotQ==",
            "authorSignature": "JoRf11Bm7z+jKbXBBXkebtH5Vnd0iqKtOw0qZV3ta5cNHNow8u71Fz7UZzBx1FqDyEKe7aSw3wJT8Og+rcaVCQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-5",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "ol5yehQMWIlnP7xWHzhos361OpTYL5SMPGDgjInAzD0=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "TEierMRyTR5lnbek",
            "ciphertext": "V071NWowphKK7ZDu4XyMVuprF4/ioPIP2eFAmm+37z/QWLsntw==",
            "authorSignature": "LMJNDoRmHHbOpn5famKyIWi/60CsxQi8zW8LuvAfXfz+H16sEic1HRHWZbg+b31XIStphGIwkCyV9d405ImiBg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-6",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "nl3DzaFF7GS5mqRzsEqj2BYLJ4WEPPH5apacNWGJ6YE=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "pDhtvAAg+yimIr88",
            "ciphertext": "YUpOmflEbD8YW8Fkf3zsoe0Cn0PyJuX4/SqOpy2ajfFWipwkGw==",
            "authorSignature": "FSxnouBIG4EY2dqTaI8kbgA+B+FQGEBNt7jSwbVTXGS4rC62LJDLKwDOAFm/UjkIyV9f54crcUU/SSgBV+TWDA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-7",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "mBjVzu9xfpX17rwDzVRO6ljuZNmM9Pm73beuaCe7CgU=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "DJHgF8yrNa9axz0k",
            "ciphertext": "PEpnfVQHUpVjl4WJIU3W1PyXosBR3faSpzbfMCeOl+Iu9UiCow==",
            "authorSignature": "Q2n0HrfLC4LDHbRfH460KldpEOIlf7cAowUb7NVCBZL20yIbXc7qbrm+i968i6AjscsnEal7NxbIiOWZwMWvBg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-8",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "JzVIOswknhtBnh0oelm2hRhCQhyStqPO0E2FBKXtHSc=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "vq4D76g9X+huF3Io",
            "ciphertext": "YKv4QS559pr+dr0WEXCYALuyN3ZXMqM7MeYnh67NAaOPv+kjBA==",
            "authorSignature": "V+7GRBzai/6cQqSm8vDo/vrY4JKBYKIy2J3DU2sTals2I+PHF6vNBOYFSVj3VMlO5xSGMllx3CmVQPJB/8+3CQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-9",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "ZOMMHK2AnAidgql8GZUv2YxaDJ3bsLzrQec1wmNluwI=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "3YQwSJD3E6c4noCZ",
            "ciphertext": "NDZVVuSu8mn2QR2cjnpwB9l8FdZeSnL/tIO/ramWT/aau60oGg==",
            "authorSignature": "AXjZ2w+V8KlXbyNnDgAMF2UOav763ZXL6ZOLKmtwUv1fQQ8gLRbRVucAVF8hoD18mDi2bhy90mJPIUNEKzhZDw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-10",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Qkd098D0WUlG/KJKGwcvAkxreQZETQgrq3PbnuVr2Lc=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "T+9XPDATIDfJ/4nB",
            "ciphertext": "Lad4NOO9F23Z+8h0o/OoWys1EAkSGv8/oZaD3IlxIbHTnlWdUQ==",
            "authorSignature": "pZ6YBsqCohfrnTv+Xo7gTioyWVq5bUHz4BJ1sz23BztecyrBIOO8I53NijxmO55+zLfkM2iR9oPKfE4j/GfiDA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-11",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Z44yA4ofBoDMF0WJBBX1tHU/tkG1ZyosmlGJBDQ2ZWw=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dWdY+tJJU/6pZ7BP",
            "ciphertext": "U5IhIs4h/MiYgl42YpvlV6aiFJAZVImYXOiZy5vV/Ggm++jpJg==",
            "authorSignature": "NgpemgZ+hZhireT092L0x0gIzzzY077PhUX3toh4LWiV4tGgjrHgDVx9uvprk6pPUYn5dfuemTL/3GZ1T7cgBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-12",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "rox1+ceRXTEVRL4ztj9bxWPvc+/yoRSPh4CARp1bxo8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "3yzJMNrC1mI2LWYd",
            "ciphertext": "BNCMt9odA3JjW0pNJcw9Qm8bnvohglaHYu1ZtXffmo8YIsfKvg==",
            "authorSignature": "Lw68wPbaf8fZkk2DWu7NneBqJoAQC91+ODjHzFFuHTEPqLoGDdRg0staZpj/KC9z+EZssuIQhnJGsdVoZ0XEDw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-13",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "7a4yG+3xXFXLhcmxd1/wFgg3i/Qcii5gIZ3ANUtnVUw=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "nAilkqKtpM60vAXH",
            "ciphertext": "VbOzdquOHcmNgK/vTMiFC4wyHakWB/bx1RItlboQFZdiyGaLzg==",
            "authorSignature": "9QkyYBmj4gbL8z4KDKeGK/SLUxzhnqs9QCEsZeQI1H5+6UqG++37e0P9FzVQpIRFrUSW2UNKT4GHK6AKupCYBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-14",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "QQXvxQJlPceEHY/finXTqS0TOucdJLt/mYxnNg9HJqg=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "/rYVak/gjvBUVmvf",
            "ciphertext": "EFMzGVsNyHCbTWSPF2d+NRyb/IO5G7SZyINVauqfViwCmeBJfw==",
            "authorSignature": "cGjD6KZ3/CoPmRixO78PiFLT0mlG/GRTzAZaAM7xBYHRFkF+2dAMwPDYPwgudNBBKbsqdfw1QRXTule0vjWHCA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-15",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Y7xyJeX7hMLeCUQMmfW2spHZUktVxrcOv80iFdc1Cj8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "C1XUGp8kiRHH0Mlc",
            "ciphertext": "VtkYILGMpVEjX9UZVaiQf79T3N01WcFipnfzZBBMgeuFHqGu8w==",
            "authorSignature": "FSpAescQA/uvaY63S/fMn5mclAyfQ4D3sMbJ6t5sTnyOvujWkaJYZleph6Ak7sFHM2vygj8Z5U/kVvVZTQwQAQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-16",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "dmthTg6w63g1aLBAxJY54oITX28UpTaVGlRbiUSuJUA=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "XeDZWBJJ8ogTFL8s",
            "ciphertext": "OsDGNK6yy/qbIDh0eaOsDIUuALpjwo5rxZtZd0hIGXLQQCaw4A==",
            "authorSignature": "WBLztcNhuBSoNx7eOUCSn+I14lcbmwXOTJccKY5ZibAUwgLogmc8zlrdyao7nj+ykggjraFPct9/HwjacPZjAQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "merge-head-1-head-2",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "4PkhyANNwBwZSX43QWh7RyK+k5gW6CFMQl1a2bb2608=",
            "parents": [
              "uMdS8LxsENhtT7ydxUHbd/1QXe9KP87a1969elNZcPg=",
              "cs/uOeh+vpuOJ1EnQTSe2E2ILsNabMfKdf/CXy3Z9Iw="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "S5eeCju7RS25Zh1i",
            "ciphertext": "oW29Qjb04jrVt1tROKCpeUOUCz7QsF1lgaczzdk0IahYCx090g==",
            "authorSignature": "ZL6C7X3YlhMKzGfI9BJ89PkWbwSRG6RAQKkzBu4fWEq+9hOKLoblVPYsNII+wCqCWwm7ede0HWvpOOIsRu7VCQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "3zNwgv6w8tVx2YhsfsToomblZJ+Z9xpaasKO2VhsT18=",
        "4PkhyANNwBwZSX43QWh7RyK+k5gW6CFMQl1a2bb2608=",
        "7a4yG+3xXFXLhcmxd1/wFgg3i/Qcii5gIZ3ANUtnVUw=",
        "8qa4eEPTozV5/+bk0gyXcYkUvPsFmzmD/IqPe5E+/bY=",
        "JzVIOswknhtBnh0oelm2hRhCQhyStqPO0E2FBKXtHSc=",
        "QQXvxQJlPceEHY/finXTqS0TOucdJLt/mYxnNg9HJqg=",
        "Qkd098D0WUlG/KJKGwcvAkxreQZETQgrq3PbnuVr2Lc=",
        "Y7xyJeX7hMLeCUQMmfW2spHZUktVxrcOv80iFdc1Cj8=",
        "Z44yA4ofBoDMF0WJBBX1tHU/tkG1ZyosmlGJBDQ2ZWw=",
        "ZOMMHK2AnAidgql8GZUv2YxaDJ3bsLzrQec1wmNluwI=",
        "dmthTg6w63g1aLBAxJY54oITX28UpTaVGlRbiUSuJUA=",
        "mBjVzu9xfpX17rwDzVRO6ljuZNmM9Pm73beuaCe7CgU=",
        "nl3DzaFF7GS5mqRzsEqj2BYLJ4WEPPH5apacNWGJ6YE=",
        "ol5yehQMWIlnP7xWHzhos361OpTYL5SMPGDgjInAzD0=",
        "rox1+ceRXTEVRL4ztj9bxWPvc+/yoRSPh4CARp1bxo8="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "seventeenth-head-rejected",
      "description": "SPEC 7.4: with sixteen heads, a client push of a seventeenth child of the root would leave 17 heads, more than the bound: too_many_heads.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "uMdS8LxsENhtT7ydxUHbd/1QXe9KP87a1969elNZcPg=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "uDS6XJj3GI/uNeEd",
            "ciphertext": "Enubp9K/EQtkQL8uRMzCv19liqONlxWIt/LRXzh+xsjTgSGvfg==",
            "authorSignature": "a0wAAxB+n94eo44XkwEVzOmd/jC/hL5RHt+SfiLTsSR5NFVX2L1QFGF7FHz9RJeqaVUgY/S78LBpo7AZoSSwDg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-2",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "cs/uOeh+vpuOJ1EnQTSe2E2ILsNabMfKdf/CXy3Z9Iw=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "K4YaHfoZu6OrWEiX",
            "ciphertext": "dFEZJpxovT2M/QQpjXt7uf0X4mE5nM3TR3esxCwUMfw4MwwRlA==",
            "authorSignature": "jxSzm2Kwh0nRNcSfM3Ay0uJF5jrYrpLyN5Ep1TX9iGN2f89s/eNyeXzZcWLFVO+AUXU2c+0lkYGQghOYt/9cDQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "8qa4eEPTozV5/+bk0gyXcYkUvPsFmzmD/IqPe5E+/bY=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "MXnxk02Yvb/ntbWO",
            "ciphertext": "YOAZ7oymqf3m5dWlPqGLZhKzemRiwHOyJUfrsDI+rti5mkHtKQ==",
            "authorSignature": "rOyqny98xUxkHvRPEklHukBLS6BZrxmf9w3d4EC9J6rdm244ZiufP0PJE1ugiZ3ulxbtF7H1iaD9K0lcblvGBw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-4",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "3zNwgv6w8tVx2YhsfsToomblZJ+Z9xpaasKO2VhsT18=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "PbdsysYC2OVrj3o8",
            "ciphertext": "+On33lAVkp0L1Ti2OQtN+616R+HlBYHSG4xe2iWZdCXj1DdotQ==",
            "authorSignature": "JoRf11Bm7z+jKbXBBXkebtH5Vnd0iqKtOw0qZV3ta5cNHNow8u71Fz7UZzBx1FqDyEKe7aSw3wJT8Og+rcaVCQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-5",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "ol5yehQMWIlnP7xWHzhos361OpTYL5SMPGDgjInAzD0=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "TEierMRyTR5lnbek",
            "ciphertext": "V071NWowphKK7ZDu4XyMVuprF4/ioPIP2eFAmm+37z/QWLsntw==",
            "authorSignature": "LMJNDoRmHHbOpn5famKyIWi/60CsxQi8zW8LuvAfXfz+H16sEic1HRHWZbg+b31XIStphGIwkCyV9d405ImiBg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-6",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "nl3DzaFF7GS5mqRzsEqj2BYLJ4WEPPH5apacNWGJ6YE=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "pDhtvAAg+yimIr88",
            "ciphertext": "YUpOmflEbD8YW8Fkf3zsoe0Cn0PyJuX4/SqOpy2ajfFWipwkGw==",
            "authorSignature": "FSxnouBIG4EY2dqTaI8kbgA+B+FQGEBNt7jSwbVTXGS4rC62LJDLKwDOAFm/UjkIyV9f54crcUU/SSgBV+TWDA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-7",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "mBjVzu9xfpX17rwDzVRO6ljuZNmM9Pm73beuaCe7CgU=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "DJHgF8yrNa9axz0k",
            "ciphertext": "PEpnfVQHUpVjl4WJIU3W1PyXosBR3faSpzbfMCeOl+Iu9UiCow==",
            "authorSignature": "Q2n0HrfLC4LDHbRfH460KldpEOIlf7cAowUb7NVCBZL20yIbXc7qbrm+i968i6AjscsnEal7NxbIiOWZwMWvBg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-8",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "JzVIOswknhtBnh0oelm2hRhCQhyStqPO0E2FBKXtHSc=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "vq4D76g9X+huF3Io",
            "ciphertext": "YKv4QS559pr+dr0WEXCYALuyN3ZXMqM7MeYnh67NAaOPv+kjBA==",
            "authorSignature": "V+7GRBzai/6cQqSm8vDo/vrY4JKBYKIy2J3DU2sTals2I+PHF6vNBOYFSVj3VMlO5xSGMllx3CmVQPJB/8+3CQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-9",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "ZOMMHK2AnAidgql8GZUv2YxaDJ3bsLzrQec1wmNluwI=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "3YQwSJD3E6c4noCZ",
            "ciphertext": "NDZVVuSu8mn2QR2cjnpwB9l8FdZeSnL/tIO/ramWT/aau60oGg==",
            "authorSignature": "AXjZ2w+V8KlXbyNnDgAMF2UOav763ZXL6ZOLKmtwUv1fQQ8gLRbRVucAVF8hoD18mDi2bhy90mJPIUNEKzhZDw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-10",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Qkd098D0WUlG/KJKGwcvAkxreQZETQgrq3PbnuVr2Lc=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "T+9XPDATIDfJ/4nB",
            "ciphertext": "Lad4NOO9F23Z+8h0o/OoWys1EAkSGv8/oZaD3IlxIbHTnlWdUQ==",
            "authorSignature": "pZ6YBsqCohfrnTv+Xo7gTioyWVq5bUHz4BJ1sz23BztecyrBIOO8I53NijxmO55+zLfkM2iR9oPKfE4j/GfiDA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-11",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Z44yA4ofBoDMF0WJBBX1tHU/tkG1ZyosmlGJBDQ2ZWw=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dWdY+tJJU/6pZ7BP",
            "ciphertext": "U5IhIs4h/MiYgl42YpvlV6aiFJAZVImYXOiZy5vV/Ggm++jpJg==",
            "authorSignature": "NgpemgZ+hZhireT092L0x0gIzzzY077PhUX3toh4LWiV4tGgjrHgDVx9uvprk6pPUYn5dfuemTL/3GZ1T7cgBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-12",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "rox1+ceRXTEVRL4ztj9bxWPvc+/yoRSPh4CARp1bxo8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "3yzJMNrC1mI2LWYd",
            "ciphertext": "BNCMt9odA3JjW0pNJcw9Qm8bnvohglaHYu1ZtXffmo8YIsfKvg==",
            "authorSignature": "Lw68wPbaf8fZkk2DWu7NneBqJoAQC91+ODjHzFFuHTEPqLoGDdRg0staZpj/KC9z+EZssuIQhnJGsdVoZ0XEDw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-13",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "7a4yG+3xXFXLhcmxd1/wFgg3i/Qcii5gIZ3ANUtnVUw=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "nAilkqKtpM60vAXH",
            "ciphertext": "VbOzdquOHcmNgK/vTMiFC4wyHakWB/bx1RItlboQFZdiyGaLzg==",
            "authorSignature": "9QkyYBmj4gbL8z4KDKeGK/SLUxzhnqs9QCEsZeQI1H5+6UqG++37e0P9FzVQpIRFrUSW2UNKT4GHK6AKupCYBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-14",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "QQXvxQJlPceEHY/finXTqS0TOucdJLt/mYxnNg9HJqg=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "/rYVak/gjvBUVmvf",
            "ciphertext": "EFMzGVsNyHCbTWSPF2d+NRyb/IO5G7SZyINVauqfViwCmeBJfw==",
            "authorSignature": "cGjD6KZ3/CoPmRixO78PiFLT0mlG/GRTzAZaAM7xBYHRFkF+2dAMwPDYPwgudNBBKbsqdfw1QRXTule0vjWHCA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-15",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Y7xyJeX7hMLeCUQMmfW2spHZUktVxrcOv80iFdc1Cj8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "C1XUGp8kiRHH0Mlc",
            "ciphertext": "VtkYILGMpVEjX9UZVaiQf79T3N01WcFipnfzZBBMgeuFHqGu8w==",
            "authorSignature": "FSpAescQA/uvaY63S/fMn5mclAyfQ4D3sMbJ6t5sTnyOvujWkaJYZleph6Ak7sFHM2vygj8Z5U/kVvVZTQwQAQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-16",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "dmthTg6w63g1aLBAxJY54oITX28UpTaVGlRbiUSuJUA=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "XeDZWBJJ8ogTFL8s",
            "ciphertext": "OsDGNK6yy/qbIDh0eaOsDIUuALpjwo5rxZtZd0hIGXLQQCaw4A==",
            "authorSignature": "WBLztcNhuBSoNx7eOUCSn+I14lcbmwXOTJccKY5ZibAUwgLogmc8zlrdyao7nj+ykggjraFPct9/HwjacPZjAQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-17",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "+UKYrvPkRw8uw6PiMddnrgyQbBkI0xCGiBYLphtiRo0=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "56mXclVTE/1ZvuMw",
            "ciphertext": "kI9Vgg0vznixUP9DIqb/WR5N+ZOFy4HjaC+gzW56bVkjW0QnSg==",
            "authorSignature": "5JJBHgoWJPl+NYannlP/jerO0z2hc6fAodxWsnpGmKL3lTO1p0ognJOlkvQ1oAlPc5Gd5oC/WuGta6DoFrWDCw=="
          },
          "expect": "too_many_heads"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "3zNwgv6w8tVx2YhsfsToomblZJ+Z9xpaasKO2VhsT18=",
        "7a4yG+3xXFXLhcmxd1/wFgg3i/Qcii5gIZ3ANUtnVUw=",
        "8qa4eEPTozV5/+bk0gyXcYkUvPsFmzmD/IqPe5E+/bY=",
        "JzVIOswknhtBnh0oelm2hRhCQhyStqPO0E2FBKXtHSc=",
        "QQXvxQJlPceEHY/finXTqS0TOucdJLt/mYxnNg9HJqg=",
        "Qkd098D0WUlG/KJKGwcvAkxreQZETQgrq3PbnuVr2Lc=",
        "Y7xyJeX7hMLeCUQMmfW2spHZUktVxrcOv80iFdc1Cj8=",
        "Z44yA4ofBoDMF0WJBBX1tHU/tkG1ZyosmlGJBDQ2ZWw=",
        "ZOMMHK2AnAidgql8GZUv2YxaDJ3bsLzrQec1wmNluwI=",
        "cs/uOeh+vpuOJ1EnQTSe2E2ILsNabMfKdf/CXy3Z9Iw=",
        "dmthTg6w63g1aLBAxJY54oITX28UpTaVGlRbiUSuJUA=",
        "mBjVzu9xfpX17rwDzVRO6ljuZNmM9Pm73beuaCe7CgU=",
        "nl3DzaFF7GS5mqRzsEqj2BYLJ4WEPPH5apacNWGJ6YE=",
        "ol5yehQMWIlnP7xWHzhos361OpTYL5SMPGDgjInAzD0=",
        "rox1+ceRXTEVRL4ztj9bxWPvc+/yoRSPh4CARp1bxo8=",
        "uMdS8LxsENhtT7ydxUHbd/1QXe9KP87a1969elNZcPg="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "head-bound-exempt-for-replication",
      "description": "SPEC 7.4, 9.1: the head bound applies to client pushes only. With sixteen heads, head-17 by replication is accepted (17 heads); a push of head-18 would leave 18: too_many_heads; a merge of two heads would leave 17 - 2 + 1 = 16 and is accepted.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "uMdS8LxsENhtT7ydxUHbd/1QXe9KP87a1969elNZcPg=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "uDS6XJj3GI/uNeEd",
            "ciphertext": "Enubp9K/EQtkQL8uRMzCv19liqONlxWIt/LRXzh+xsjTgSGvfg==",
            "authorSignature": "a0wAAxB+n94eo44XkwEVzOmd/jC/hL5RHt+SfiLTsSR5NFVX2L1QFGF7FHz9RJeqaVUgY/S78LBpo7AZoSSwDg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-2",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "cs/uOeh+vpuOJ1EnQTSe2E2ILsNabMfKdf/CXy3Z9Iw=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "K4YaHfoZu6OrWEiX",
            "ciphertext": "dFEZJpxovT2M/QQpjXt7uf0X4mE5nM3TR3esxCwUMfw4MwwRlA==",
            "authorSignature": "jxSzm2Kwh0nRNcSfM3Ay0uJF5jrYrpLyN5Ep1TX9iGN2f89s/eNyeXzZcWLFVO+AUXU2c+0lkYGQghOYt/9cDQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "8qa4eEPTozV5/+bk0gyXcYkUvPsFmzmD/IqPe5E+/bY=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "MXnxk02Yvb/ntbWO",
            "ciphertext": "YOAZ7oymqf3m5dWlPqGLZhKzemRiwHOyJUfrsDI+rti5mkHtKQ==",
            "authorSignature": "rOyqny98xUxkHvRPEklHukBLS6BZrxmf9w3d4EC9J6rdm244ZiufP0PJE1ugiZ3ulxbtF7H1iaD9K0lcblvGBw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-4",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "3zNwgv6w8tVx2YhsfsToomblZJ+Z9xpaasKO2VhsT18=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "PbdsysYC2OVrj3o8",
            "ciphertext": "+On33lAVkp0L1Ti2OQtN+616R+HlBYHSG4xe2iWZdCXj1DdotQ==",
            "authorSignature": "JoRf11Bm7z+jKbXBBXkebtH5Vnd0iqKtOw0qZV3ta5cNHNow8u71Fz7UZzBx1FqDyEKe7aSw3wJT8Og+rcaVCQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-5",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "ol5yehQMWIlnP7xWHzhos361OpTYL5SMPGDgjInAzD0=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "TEierMRyTR5lnbek",
            "ciphertext": "V071NWowphKK7ZDu4XyMVuprF4/ioPIP2eFAmm+37z/QWLsntw==",
            "authorSignature": "LMJNDoRmHHbOpn5famKyIWi/60CsxQi8zW8LuvAfXfz+H16sEic1HRHWZbg+b31XIStphGIwkCyV9d405ImiBg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-6",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "nl3DzaFF7GS5mqRzsEqj2BYLJ4WEPPH5apacNWGJ6YE=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "pDhtvAAg+yimIr88",
            "ciphertext": "YUpOmflEbD8YW8Fkf3zsoe0Cn0PyJuX4/SqOpy2ajfFWipwkGw==",
            "authorSignature": "FSxnouBIG4EY2dqTaI8kbgA+B+FQGEBNt7jSwbVTXGS4rC62LJDLKwDOAFm/UjkIyV9f54crcUU/SSgBV+TWDA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-7",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "mBjVzu9xfpX17rwDzVRO6ljuZNmM9Pm73beuaCe7CgU=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "DJHgF8yrNa9axz0k",
            "ciphertext": "PEpnfVQHUpVjl4WJIU3W1PyXosBR3faSpzbfMCeOl+Iu9UiCow==",
            "authorSignature": "Q2n0HrfLC4LDHbRfH460KldpEOIlf7cAowUb7NVCBZL20yIbXc7qbrm+i968i6AjscsnEal7NxbIiOWZwMWvBg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-8",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "JzVIOswknhtBnh0oelm2hRhCQhyStqPO0E2FBKXtHSc=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "vq4D76g9X+huF3Io",
            "ciphertext": "YKv4QS559pr+dr0WEXCYALuyN3ZXMqM7MeYnh67NAaOPv+kjBA==",
            "authorSignature": "V+7GRBzai/6cQqSm8vDo/vrY4JKBYKIy2J3DU2sTals2I+PHF6vNBOYFSVj3VMlO5xSGMllx3CmVQPJB/8+3CQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-9",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "ZOMMHK2AnAidgql8GZUv2YxaDJ3bsLzrQec1wmNluwI=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "3YQwSJD3E6c4noCZ",
            "ciphertext": "NDZVVuSu8mn2QR2cjnpwB9l8FdZeSnL/tIO/ramWT/aau60oGg==",
            "authorSignature": "AXjZ2w+V8KlXbyNnDgAMF2UOav763ZXL6ZOLKmtwUv1fQQ8gLRbRVucAVF8hoD18mDi2bhy90mJPIUNEKzhZDw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-10",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Qkd098D0WUlG/KJKGwcvAkxreQZETQgrq3PbnuVr2Lc=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "T+9XPDATIDfJ/4nB",
            "ciphertext": "Lad4NOO9F23Z+8h0o/OoWys1EAkSGv8/oZaD3IlxIbHTnlWdUQ==",
            "authorSignature": "pZ6YBsqCohfrnTv+Xo7gTioyWVq5bUHz4BJ1sz23BztecyrBIOO8I53NijxmO55+zLfkM2iR9oPKfE4j/GfiDA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-11",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Z44yA4ofBoDMF0WJBBX1tHU/tkG1ZyosmlGJBDQ2ZWw=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dWdY+tJJU/6pZ7BP",
            "ciphertext": "U5IhIs4h/MiYgl42YpvlV6aiFJAZVImYXOiZy5vV/Ggm++jpJg==",
            "authorSignature": "NgpemgZ+hZhireT092L0x0gIzzzY077PhUX3toh4LWiV4tGgjrHgDVx9uvprk6pPUYn5dfuemTL/3GZ1T7cgBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-12",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "rox1+ceRXTEVRL4ztj9bxWPvc+/yoRSPh4CARp1bxo8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "3yzJMNrC1mI2LWYd",
            "ciphertext": "BNCMt9odA3JjW0pNJcw9Qm8bnvohglaHYu1ZtXffmo8YIsfKvg==",
            "authorSignature": "Lw68wPbaf8fZkk2DWu7NneBqJoAQC91+ODjHzFFuHTEPqLoGDdRg0staZpj/KC9z+EZssuIQhnJGsdVoZ0XEDw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-13",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "7a4yG+3xXFXLhcmxd1/wFgg3i/Qcii5gIZ3ANUtnVUw=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "nAilkqKtpM60vAXH",
            "ciphertext": "VbOzdquOHcmNgK/vTMiFC4wyHakWB/bx1RItlboQFZdiyGaLzg==",
            "authorSignature": "9QkyYBmj4gbL8z4KDKeGK/SLUxzhnqs9QCEsZeQI1H5+6UqG++37e0P9FzVQpIRFrUSW2UNKT4GHK6AKupCYBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-14",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "QQXvxQJlPceEHY/finXTqS0TOucdJLt/mYxnNg9HJqg=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "/rYVak/gjvBUVmvf",
            "ciphertext": "EFMzGVsNyHCbTWSPF2d+NRyb/IO5G7SZyINVauqfViwCmeBJfw==",
            "authorSignature": "cGjD6KZ3/CoPmRixO78PiFLT0mlG/GRTzAZaAM7xBYHRFkF+2dAMwPDYPwgudNBBKbsqdfw1QRXTule0vjWHCA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-15",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Y7xyJeX7hMLeCUQMmfW2spHZUktVxrcOv80iFdc1Cj8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "C1XUGp8kiRHH0Mlc",
            "ciphertext": "VtkYILGMpVEjX9UZVaiQf79T3N01WcFipnfzZBBMgeuFHqGu8w==",
            "authorSignature": "FSpAescQA/uvaY63S/fMn5mclAyfQ4D3sMbJ6t5sTnyOvujWkaJYZleph6Ak7sFHM2vygj8Z5U/kVvVZTQwQAQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-16",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "dmthTg6w63g1aLBAxJY54oITX28UpTaVGlRbiUSuJUA=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "XeDZWBJJ8ogTFL8s",
            "ciphertext": "OsDGNK6yy/qbIDh0eaOsDIUuALpjwo5rxZtZd0hIGXLQQCaw4A==",
            "authorSignature": "WBLztcNhuBSoNx7eOUCSn+I14lcbmwXOTJccKY5ZibAUwgLogmc8zlrdyao7nj+ykggjraFPct9/HwjacPZjAQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "head-17",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "+UKYrvPkRw8uw6PiMddnrgyQbBkI0xCGiBYLphtiRo0=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "56mXclVTE/1ZvuMw",
            "ciphertext": "kI9Vgg0vznixUP9DIqb/WR5N+ZOFy4HjaC+gzW56bVkjW0QnSg==",
            "authorSignature": "5JJBHgoWJPl+NYannlP/jerO0z2hc6fAodxWsnpGmKL3lTO1p0ognJOlkvQ1oAlPc5Gd5oC/WuGta6DoFrWDCw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "head-18",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "JibFWQ73HxnJft25KNP6VohjGauBXBqvYFSOw84K/E0=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "tf/TzA3lIg7YrCnY",
            "ciphertext": "nMTM3LPdh/koiuW8QZtDsP9B70x3jlSr6hqYVLZ+fEmm/fTF1w==",
            "authorSignature": "/N2q66BaKwEaOJdROU0CVFHTVtLilzFCr48hyBD6fgP2OK9z/SsOu1OuGo7rCEDmgI8pSMbc/BDFjRGUSUrDBQ=="
          },
          "expect": "too_many_heads"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "merge-head-1-head-2",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "4PkhyANNwBwZSX43QWh7RyK+k5gW6CFMQl1a2bb2608=",
            "parents": [
              "uMdS8LxsENhtT7ydxUHbd/1QXe9KP87a1969elNZcPg=",
              "cs/uOeh+vpuOJ1EnQTSe2E2ILsNabMfKdf/CXy3Z9Iw="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "S5eeCju7RS25Zh1i",
            "ciphertext": "oW29Qjb04jrVt1tROKCpeUOUCz7QsF1lgaczzdk0IahYCx090g==",
            "authorSignature": "ZL6C7X3YlhMKzGfI9BJ89PkWbwSRG6RAQKkzBu4fWEq+9hOKLoblVPYsNII+wCqCWwm7ede0HWvpOOIsRu7VCQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "+UKYrvPkRw8uw6PiMddnrgyQbBkI0xCGiBYLphtiRo0=",
        "3zNwgv6w8tVx2YhsfsToomblZJ+Z9xpaasKO2VhsT18=",
        "4PkhyANNwBwZSX43QWh7RyK+k5gW6CFMQl1a2bb2608=",
        "7a4yG+3xXFXLhcmxd1/wFgg3i/Qcii5gIZ3ANUtnVUw=",
        "8qa4eEPTozV5/+bk0gyXcYkUvPsFmzmD/IqPe5E+/bY=",
        "JzVIOswknhtBnh0oelm2hRhCQhyStqPO0E2FBKXtHSc=",
        "QQXvxQJlPceEHY/finXTqS0TOucdJLt/mYxnNg9HJqg=",
        "Qkd098D0WUlG/KJKGwcvAkxreQZETQgrq3PbnuVr2Lc=",
        "Y7xyJeX7hMLeCUQMmfW2spHZUktVxrcOv80iFdc1Cj8=",
        "Z44yA4ofBoDMF0WJBBX1tHU/tkG1ZyosmlGJBDQ2ZWw=",
        "ZOMMHK2AnAidgql8GZUv2YxaDJ3bsLzrQec1wmNluwI=",
        "dmthTg6w63g1aLBAxJY54oITX28UpTaVGlRbiUSuJUA=",
        "mBjVzu9xfpX17rwDzVRO6ljuZNmM9Pm73beuaCe7CgU=",
        "nl3DzaFF7GS5mqRzsEqj2BYLJ4WEPPH5apacNWGJ6YE=",
        "ol5yehQMWIlnP7xWHzhos361OpTYL5SMPGDgjInAzD0=",
        "rox1+ceRXTEVRL4ztj9bxWPvc+/yoRSPh4CARp1bxo8="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "removed-member-frontier-ok",
      "description": "SPEC 7.3, 8.3: seq 3 removes bob with frontier {a1, b1, b2}; the rotation commit merges a1 and b1. b2, bob's commit the owner saw but this host had not, then arrives by replication: its id is in the frontier, so it is accepted (citing seq 2 at epoch 0) and is a head beside the rotation commit.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "NBKmJpxb1+aVBlmZ+w9zfRzrifgxeTPFs8FYr54VTZr+5ofVcIUStwyeCJ1c2HrmPjLBWDLHK3TiyW60t6nYAg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "ja7DPQSFiSKcH8/P",
            "ciphertext": "LCwZLe1snwQHUL00n9nTotPVnv4uv5wI4NrxeswHPKDMlBSTqg==",
            "authorSignature": "ZSzcMthK/wLlICIQskYQusscst9+emsKrMGQtg6SFhBPMkap5ud1e33eyDzSNLmxT05LhbNSK4n38wgJrUobCg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
                      "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
                      "SJy9WFy4GPbDfiFAq89yqznBiP9CTPShLjfwmwhfeTU="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "/Nsi4Ch6Z2lBmvA1NaEpbFqRgEluCFeVTJpRb68BEbIGkn5Mn1+7pnkuo0jieEawevZfubS+lHc5r686MBDKCw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "YLG5Doxc6idWIA0v/p1bE5SA2wQfoDjgnXDPsF5RRMc=",
              "parents": [
                "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
                "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "B0Xe27eqgqjWriaSvEZjzTn257/7rTS1KctwsNrb/iU=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JvWulNZs5gpJXSS2",
              "ciphertext": "lU6AXvJAJkg/57Xwx9EUmrZFegP9+yCLpWpThG1/E4I/z7kC0w==",
              "authorSignature": "50h8TJbGFq2UpY3BuZOyapDB0gDmaet10LlSjrVgOx7XDM4qGACPWXqcOasd2WHLUZ5/cgJsSgoJyICRPR2QAw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b2",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "SJy9WFy4GPbDfiFAq89yqznBiP9CTPShLjfwmwhfeTU=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "O9WiwvR1GGUyhcaY",
            "ciphertext": "z4oc/p2iyW/dQcxM5pnF6arYkwp6ykeEexvYDLQvLMfel1uCXw==",
            "authorSignature": "6HgoGO1MP0V3locpraRCx6k8ntnrBkG0QjFROmuUWXz4X7BTSbddnmap1mHE8A1FDbGltJM4u7HT5mE7WUQmBQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "SJy9WFy4GPbDfiFAq89yqznBiP9CTPShLjfwmwhfeTU=",
        "YLG5Doxc6idWIA0v/p1bE5SA2wQfoDjgnXDPsF5RRMc="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "B0Xe27eqgqjWriaSvEZjzTn257/7rTS1KctwsNrb/iU="
    },
    {
      "name": "removed-member-after-cutoff",
      "description": "SPEC 7.3, 7.4: after seq 3 removes bob with frontier {a1, b1}, bob's b3 (a child of the root, citing seq 2 at epoch 0) is neither in the frontier nor an ancestor of a frontier commit: forbidden by replication and on push. alice's child of b3 then has a rejected parent: forbidden.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "NBKmJpxb1+aVBlmZ+w9zfRzrifgxeTPFs8FYr54VTZr+5ofVcIUStwyeCJ1c2HrmPjLBWDLHK3TiyW60t6nYAg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "ja7DPQSFiSKcH8/P",
            "ciphertext": "LCwZLe1snwQHUL00n9nTotPVnv4uv5wI4NrxeswHPKDMlBSTqg==",
            "authorSignature": "ZSzcMthK/wLlICIQskYQusscst9+emsKrMGQtg6SFhBPMkap5ud1e33eyDzSNLmxT05LhbNSK4n38wgJrUobCg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
                      "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "eLZOZGkKhAt5qvJ5N+BZ+MAUrl3X8TND1hci1vOKl2upzq+cHD2Y/sM598NseUsuNzyYQKqgwe7gOFl4dkewCg=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "mXGBcLk0LAd12PAmgKYM9Ft7i0iJ2D972TiRT9mtjzY=",
              "parents": [
                "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
                "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "y0oVNrP6TFbXNdgD1dOxjD7cjLKPuFMEP9zOKdSHZVY=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JvWulNZs5gpJXSS2",
              "ciphertext": "lU6AXvJAJkg/57Xwx9EUmrZFegP9+yCLpWpThG1/E4I/z7kC0w==",
              "authorSignature": "zPiaPnCsUSPWeSPV/fF9s//9082mMEiXkcMYj+P6PBznELX/Hpbz7okEBaS0W9TK05ejULUlL7gP92UCV4OHAQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b3-after-cutoff",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "8xskwTqODNV7/Mcejgs7ynxLSIkUb8sUAegqSO3FVwA=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "sDku3IriuGv9ZNR3",
            "ciphertext": "5vvV89f6HVXrDYUhcDXNldlWnEqffeed9J+15/NU+8LO5Up2mw==",
            "authorSignature": "1Aaeyzjsax8WJnb0+TvhjXFn1mCSidvywW74VlXA+fIYwn4RruoExVlEJIkHIpgaEv8+U3qWObNjg6A3c9iZAA=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b3-after-cutoff",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "8xskwTqODNV7/Mcejgs7ynxLSIkUb8sUAegqSO3FVwA=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "sDku3IriuGv9ZNR3",
            "ciphertext": "5vvV89f6HVXrDYUhcDXNldlWnEqffeed9J+15/NU+8LO5Up2mw==",
            "authorSignature": "1Aaeyzjsax8WJnb0+TvhjXFn1mCSidvywW74VlXA+fIYwn4RruoExVlEJIkHIpgaEv8+U3qWObNjg6A3c9iZAA=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a2-child-of-b3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "T0bGchUkPxxNiSsoMeGNvrVORU4FNAW4dUBDUg4rwn4=",
            "parents": [
              "8xskwTqODNV7/Mcejgs7ynxLSIkUb8sUAegqSO3FVwA="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "y0oVNrP6TFbXNdgD1dOxjD7cjLKPuFMEP9zOKdSHZVY=",
            "keyEpoch": 1,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "YZPRU0jqO0Yp039a",
            "ciphertext": "F1kZYmtY6krwIOlf5L9zB6KkEL4ISyKFC0d6VzOvTv9KEdsTzg==",
            "authorSignature": "blEQ770b2xIN4ZU1BahVoktbH4/icOw9rqkXWEmKB6WBOxYo8QvST8+6T6QBqoN4OTNToQ9HncOVjaHWA3YBDA=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "mXGBcLk0LAd12PAmgKYM9Ft7i0iJ2D972TiRT9mtjzY="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "y0oVNrP6TFbXNdgD1dOxjD7cjLKPuFMEP9zOKdSHZVY="
    },
    {
      "name": "removed-member-backdated-child-of-frontier",
      "description": "SPEC 7.3: after bob's removal with frontier {a1, b1}, bob backdates b4 citing seq 2 at epoch 0 with parent b1, which is in the frontier. b4's own id is neither in the frontier nor an ancestor of a frontier commit, so it MUST be rejected: forbidden by replication and on push.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "NBKmJpxb1+aVBlmZ+w9zfRzrifgxeTPFs8FYr54VTZr+5ofVcIUStwyeCJ1c2HrmPjLBWDLHK3TiyW60t6nYAg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "ja7DPQSFiSKcH8/P",
            "ciphertext": "LCwZLe1snwQHUL00n9nTotPVnv4uv5wI4NrxeswHPKDMlBSTqg==",
            "authorSignature": "ZSzcMthK/wLlICIQskYQusscst9+emsKrMGQtg6SFhBPMkap5ud1e33eyDzSNLmxT05LhbNSK4n38wgJrUobCg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
                      "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "eLZOZGkKhAt5qvJ5N+BZ+MAUrl3X8TND1hci1vOKl2upzq+cHD2Y/sM598NseUsuNzyYQKqgwe7gOFl4dkewCg=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "mXGBcLk0LAd12PAmgKYM9Ft7i0iJ2D972TiRT9mtjzY=",
              "parents": [
                "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
                "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "y0oVNrP6TFbXNdgD1dOxjD7cjLKPuFMEP9zOKdSHZVY=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JvWulNZs5gpJXSS2",
              "ciphertext": "lU6AXvJAJkg/57Xwx9EUmrZFegP9+yCLpWpThG1/E4I/z7kC0w==",
              "authorSignature": "zPiaPnCsUSPWeSPV/fF9s//9082mMEiXkcMYj+P6PBznELX/Hpbz7okEBaS0W9TK05ejULUlL7gP92UCV4OHAQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b4-child-of-b1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "5UDv9BL9cSWZpMDeBXHD/bai6ZKavzT4A2YfqPGaoyI=",
            "parents": [
              "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "3dGdq4y348guqjMP",
            "ciphertext": "PxFcWRGcrR5m9uESABM76siF8ypnK+pYKlIk6og/9VVf6LliTg==",
            "authorSignature": "1uNLT8GSpeP/uxK8ZK1kjbLLiOB5rfnIYW4dzLHFVEYtbJuagBwJRcAwUtxOeOD8G0H932A60eysuR1NsTWBCg=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b4-child-of-b1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "5UDv9BL9cSWZpMDeBXHD/bai6ZKavzT4A2YfqPGaoyI=",
            "parents": [
              "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "3dGdq4y348guqjMP",
            "ciphertext": "PxFcWRGcrR5m9uESABM76siF8ypnK+pYKlIk6og/9VVf6LliTg==",
            "authorSignature": "1uNLT8GSpeP/uxK8ZK1kjbLLiOB5rfnIYW4dzLHFVEYtbJuagBwJRcAwUtxOeOD8G0H932A60eysuR1NsTWBCg=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "mXGBcLk0LAd12PAmgKYM9Ft7i0iJ2D972TiRT9mtjzY="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "y0oVNrP6TFbXNdgD1dOxjD7cjLKPuFMEP9zOKdSHZVY="
    },
    {
      "name": "removed-member-ancestor-of-frontier",
      "description": "SPEC 7.3: the frontier is {a1, b1, b2} and b2's parent is b0, both unseen here. b0 first: the host lacks frontier commit b2 and cannot decide, so missing_parents. b2: in the frontier but its parent b0 is unknown, missing_parents (its verified header now counts for ancestry). b0 again: an ancestor of frontier commit b2, accepted. b2 again: accepted.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "NBKmJpxb1+aVBlmZ+w9zfRzrifgxeTPFs8FYr54VTZr+5ofVcIUStwyeCJ1c2HrmPjLBWDLHK3TiyW60t6nYAg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "ja7DPQSFiSKcH8/P",
            "ciphertext": "LCwZLe1snwQHUL00n9nTotPVnv4uv5wI4NrxeswHPKDMlBSTqg==",
            "authorSignature": "ZSzcMthK/wLlICIQskYQusscst9+emsKrMGQtg6SFhBPMkap5ud1e33eyDzSNLmxT05LhbNSK4n38wgJrUobCg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
                      "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
                      "TbkspYmn4R/mXzIhJf2TFihYYv/jPN8FKuGtAAugB+w="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "6dcTeBZ14k6x5g75hHy5dvODqk5/lN7uxSSJKmEyGuNPJyZYusaRIRISTH+0Ix/oZc7bSr4sWQnRkbrYWWQlAw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "2ASdG62vUEn/Fxm7AXm3nCV3PuScjDLzqLMlVCk9I68=",
              "parents": [
                "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
                "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "qwThlLaTH99+roexljFa8C0Ubt5v8x0s2tadIx388ZQ=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JvWulNZs5gpJXSS2",
              "ciphertext": "lU6AXvJAJkg/57Xwx9EUmrZFegP9+yCLpWpThG1/E4I/z7kC0w==",
              "authorSignature": "eKQ2Zz0/aCHJ8WI32/Y9H6YyUXr8DbMvF3nHfW5wAvhff4lDzagtGarKPxAUfShy4EIR+4cCyMw5N90Z3W8UAA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b0",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "g1n5B32bi3vq3pQ0LXs0I9xkWixHMkjbzKy3WxAntFk=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "TwTDpsYBoai+1J4x",
            "ciphertext": "na9kai6qsBKO6ADorxbC3lhu1x9FTwvUO0VEtnwLqFVq2w2EmQ==",
            "authorSignature": "pvNhqRXiSLUfzMnsq/ftQTB+ERqSFjNGr/C3CSaWKMWuLx6y6OKIg910tZSe8ZghGrkBoFXJfO3aB65R+BWVDw=="
          },
          "expect": "missing_parents"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b2-child-of-b0",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "TbkspYmn4R/mXzIhJf2TFihYYv/jPN8FKuGtAAugB+w=",
            "parents": [
              "g1n5B32bi3vq3pQ0LXs0I9xkWixHMkjbzKy3WxAntFk="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "5/5kheNZqVhfgLer",
            "ciphertext": "YS6KpCJ7tqQSuDYIo92xe+aFj99gBU+w9apIN1nLhfC0Bx0isQ==",
            "authorSignature": "Qh967slOL40bTQIu37mCbOZ/kWjkh/X71U/lnWggDSboQWuT1KQdNfTPppcGH4uC7sbv316DPLwRb3LeWvQ/CQ=="
          },
          "expect": "missing_parents"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b0",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "g1n5B32bi3vq3pQ0LXs0I9xkWixHMkjbzKy3WxAntFk=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "TwTDpsYBoai+1J4x",
            "ciphertext": "na9kai6qsBKO6ADorxbC3lhu1x9FTwvUO0VEtnwLqFVq2w2EmQ==",
            "authorSignature": "pvNhqRXiSLUfzMnsq/ftQTB+ERqSFjNGr/C3CSaWKMWuLx6y6OKIg910tZSe8ZghGrkBoFXJfO3aB65R+BWVDw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b2-child-of-b0",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "TbkspYmn4R/mXzIhJf2TFihYYv/jPN8FKuGtAAugB+w=",
            "parents": [
              "g1n5B32bi3vq3pQ0LXs0I9xkWixHMkjbzKy3WxAntFk="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "5/5kheNZqVhfgLer",
            "ciphertext": "YS6KpCJ7tqQSuDYIo92xe+aFj99gBU+w9apIN1nLhfC0Bx0isQ==",
            "authorSignature": "Qh967slOL40bTQIu37mCbOZ/kWjkh/X71U/lnWggDSboQWuT1KQdNfTPppcGH4uC7sbv316DPLwRb3LeWvQ/CQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "2ASdG62vUEn/Fxm7AXm3nCV3PuScjDLzqLMlVCk9I68=",
        "TbkspYmn4R/mXzIhJf2TFihYYv/jPN8FKuGtAAugB+w="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "qwThlLaTH99+roexljFa8C0Ubt5v8x0s2tadIx388ZQ="
    },
    {
      "name": "removed-member-dropped-on-removal",
      "description": "SPEC 7.3: this host holds bob's head b1, which never reached the owner; seq 3 removes bob with frontier {a1}. On accepting it the host re-checks bob's commits and drops b1 from the heads; alice's later child of b1 has a rejected parent: forbidden.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "NBKmJpxb1+aVBlmZ+w9zfRzrifgxeTPFs8FYr54VTZr+5ofVcIUStwyeCJ1c2HrmPjLBWDLHK3TiyW60t6nYAg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b1-unseen-by-owner",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "dGVa2If2f1b0SetlpQ5hSlhqb1/pYeomRaiPxUbhG/I=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "vcxReUfHF/fSY4S9",
            "ciphertext": "wt4ahgcncSnZoST3+ukOSNIgIC2uf3000abOIcrSPvhzwXsing==",
            "authorSignature": "bztrB6lxx/1EwQV34sAJp+QTobPRi/GAfJlli+8ZHHZl9OdB1bViavmyT16P/00zaInfeEtI9wVLV3ooL7MbAA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "APAD1pNgSRaHbyG18IOf4FsOBDu8izX2IPbEWGmJKz6m0HNB4/+pqIyloKllsDzyj5Ra3OtVEkDSZ6hUV/tfCQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "zNL1voUNfbkvPUKuVOj6yh2F9ArCMEsTKUIckIo/vic=",
              "parents": [
                "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "B3lRKiWsQo7V9GgORnF2YokpQs5NKiM4qZtiZ2hRIek=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JvWulNZs5gpJXSS2",
              "ciphertext": "lU6AXvJAJkg/57Xwx9EUmrZFegP9k9s/ReIZat0dGsEoSsuchg==",
              "authorSignature": "5B44zF9mQkIZFDZWhVEvkNYJs7yiw2vsQi5zzmxxCPxki6eH8fZ8lMMZwq2wjxieBQR3CTcJTAKzdT9JXKWYBQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a2-child-of-b1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "jWCDNBOYFWqQzQ7hXqzHyHe1wAQQswqen2faEjUNBfU=",
            "parents": [
              "dGVa2If2f1b0SetlpQ5hSlhqb1/pYeomRaiPxUbhG/I="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "B3lRKiWsQo7V9GgORnF2YokpQs5NKiM4qZtiZ2hRIek=",
            "keyEpoch": 1,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "i4AlUUP30rA1jiNX",
            "ciphertext": "CFPSdwvMEIri1vUihl/4WJfkLadQGfhduiAxh+BlqLrDHtOe1Q==",
            "authorSignature": "xauX/YWO7CWHgoQLxncrDsUjr0dCW1Vnyfx+dDrLP7HIxUYrbbzMHy7HzoI0iSdABXPIYJ7t0VMJl/T5yEmkBw=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "zNL1voUNfbkvPUKuVOj6yh2F9ArCMEsTKUIckIo/vic="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "B3lRKiWsQo7V9GgORnF2YokpQs5NKiM4qZtiZ2hRIek="
    },
    {
      "name": "rotation-without-commit",
      "description": "SPEC 8.3, 9.1: seq 3 removes bob and raises the epoch; without its rotation commit it is rejected with bad_request, by replication and on publish. Published with it, both are accepted.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "M3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "aIx2pt4lP3Y3wSWtuzHtCLpsnYVw4XlhgWVPJOc5zuQlny3KVg+Z820IHmJ0iDQvnnYbnQvKtT75xNA2ln4kDw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "aIx2pt4lP3Y3wSWtuzHtCLpsnYVw4XlhgWVPJOc5zuQlny3KVg+Z820IHmJ0iDQvnnYbnQvKtT75xNA2ln4kDw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "aIx2pt4lP3Y3wSWtuzHtCLpsnYVw4XlhgWVPJOc5zuQlny3KVg+Z820IHmJ0iDQvnnYbnQvKtT75xNA2ln4kDw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "UidzS/j8L2ZLh8v5foloSNlUfZz1+WIJyol1XOC90zQ=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JvWulNZs5gpJXSS2",
              "ciphertext": "lU6AXvJAJkg/57Xwx9EUmrZFegP9QwcgW6+5QdoGVGBf1vS2Nw==",
              "authorSignature": "bOJu/Ika0LN+9gKXPvxHU3COk2Nmp44hSnzPH7Dmj4jiafOjcKVbPxr6Nism4k6O0dSM+qxaqob7mGaZv0L0Bw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "UidzS/j8L2ZLh8v5foloSNlUfZz1+WIJyol1XOC90zQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ="
    },
    {
      "name": "rotation-commit-not-owner",
      "description": "SPEC 8.3: the rotation commit of an epoch-raising state MUST be authored by ownerKey; one by alice is bad_request and the state is not adopted either (atomic).",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot-by-alice",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "aIx2pt4lP3Y3wSWtuzHtCLpsnYVw4XlhgWVPJOc5zuQlny3KVg+Z820IHmJ0iDQvnnYbnQvKtT75xNA2ln4kDw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "CAV2awNqe7fO9ha7QbilaOErHOGJP0BVQTDoVDtTUVE=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
              "iv": "UtgTEta75edw1167",
              "ciphertext": "HxyuhHqz2bTRy+sLzWHun2jZWci/9vIoA9uytphvFxdapPK5rw==",
              "authorSignature": "GN7JAHrdHak2lJby33geGGZM6ri2LRMOgjFu8y6wa4XHCykb2ugjOz8SfAvyqBwd6Lhm26NC1APgbL0K1oJEBw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0="
    },
    {
      "name": "rotation-commit-wrong-epoch",
      "description": "SPEC 8.3: the rotation commit MUST be at the new epoch (1); one at epoch 0 is bad_request and the state is not adopted.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot-epoch-0",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "aIx2pt4lP3Y3wSWtuzHtCLpsnYVw4XlhgWVPJOc5zuQlny3KVg+Z820IHmJ0iDQvnnYbnQvKtT75xNA2ln4kDw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "fVHo1yeiNk1D3xGHYWIu3nx0JPcz8+IbZU4K8H/Ex44=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "SuvKJZAHTxNT1qMY",
              "ciphertext": "eii+pA6gNjRHwOD9OuAi6bJPd1+KJsCjlwSqXpvSygsLR1bl0Q==",
              "authorSignature": "zD9r99DzvMTQ5k5EdoGAteLy7l9ZLqQiCuX5kICEA3McL/NRLUib0QwoEWNzujLojerVimb1EfulvXXLZx+MDg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0="
    },
    {
      "name": "rotation-commit-missing-parent",
      "description": "SPEC 8.3 atomicity, 7.2, 7.4: the rotation commit's parent x is unknown, so the pair answers missing_parents and neither is stored: alice's commit citing seq 3 then gets missing_parents too (unknown state). Once x is accepted, the pair and then alice's commit are accepted.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "G//6YtChbyyXg9JEGh4JKqsUynFG92xutckfAg5IqnM="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "gflpgrfC4sDA56RDTom1DyMXftAaBXHtj7qK/9/hlEQMvq8oAuMAkIX7fX2b6xdRUnap7lmPJNl7EAb20029Ag=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "KmS//xA/jhFCwtvUhGxsL7oBRKDGEL61p+qhCclsCqs=",
              "parents": [
                "G//6YtChbyyXg9JEGh4JKqsUynFG92xutckfAg5IqnM="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "A6X1WDQjhaS9asDl2R6/Ewv1ze1IOX/tpYOd4Uea9h4=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JvWulNZs5gpJXSS2",
              "ciphertext": "lU6AXvJAJkg/57Xwx9EUmrZFegP9QmaHUk5wwOYLXMiVSXY1BA==",
              "authorSignature": "BEEA6n+9V+Sm5aL/rbIdEu3Hp9wkOAzktv2upVlPimLA77/hKTbr87b+farmAdIfplbqeHlQH+6pH6ifvxTCCg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "missing_parents"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a3-cites-seq-3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "OA4FehhdKA6HkQ/EvT9L/2bBpAxQ5OVzzXMkTu2/u0I=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "A6X1WDQjhaS9asDl2R6/Ewv1ze1IOX/tpYOd4Uea9h4=",
            "keyEpoch": 1,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "Ywkc5vwoIumy3Ypg",
            "ciphertext": "F9XFvz3lKyPG40iyKnOYRhqmpCnF5cimLWhCz0JcW6wGbY38Hw==",
            "authorSignature": "k79YtJUEJNxpj7d25PXJzK1ZnksfBgU76bFzwnPCTB4iUEOkNwSyfG3S3HGw4WChurPWdHnIxg15pZUiNzqHCg=="
          },
          "expect": "missing_parents"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "x",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "G//6YtChbyyXg9JEGh4JKqsUynFG92xutckfAg5IqnM=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "NXqHrsubb4BKBeea",
            "ciphertext": "yGY0nqB1AbzS2oJ2OUCmBNMnS4AHC1ni2vzq6pH2EUOmPo8eNQ==",
            "authorSignature": "EooOxOdS++a8z7jmNH9tUApOcaTVlrfl1u501Di6m51YkiHJTffnmAeQxkAXUaDvePJB2xIDs+YnEgzpapodCQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "G//6YtChbyyXg9JEGh4JKqsUynFG92xutckfAg5IqnM="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "gflpgrfC4sDA56RDTom1DyMXftAaBXHtj7qK/9/hlEQMvq8oAuMAkIX7fX2b6xdRUnap7lmPJNl7EAb20029Ag=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "KmS//xA/jhFCwtvUhGxsL7oBRKDGEL61p+qhCclsCqs=",
              "parents": [
                "G//6YtChbyyXg9JEGh4JKqsUynFG92xutckfAg5IqnM="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "A6X1WDQjhaS9asDl2R6/Ewv1ze1IOX/tpYOd4Uea9h4=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JvWulNZs5gpJXSS2",
              "ciphertext": "lU6AXvJAJkg/57Xwx9EUmrZFegP9QmaHUk5wwOYLXMiVSXY1BA==",
              "authorSignature": "BEEA6n+9V+Sm5aL/rbIdEu3Hp9wkOAzktv2upVlPimLA77/hKTbr87b+farmAdIfplbqeHlQH+6pH6ifvxTCCg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a3-cites-seq-3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "OA4FehhdKA6HkQ/EvT9L/2bBpAxQ5OVzzXMkTu2/u0I=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "A6X1WDQjhaS9asDl2R6/Ewv1ze1IOX/tpYOd4Uea9h4=",
            "keyEpoch": 1,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "Ywkc5vwoIumy3Ypg",
            "ciphertext": "F9XFvz3lKyPG40iyKnOYRhqmpCnF5cimLWhCz0JcW6wGbY38Hw==",
            "authorSignature": "k79YtJUEJNxpj7d25PXJzK1ZnksfBgU76bFzwnPCTB4iUEOkNwSyfG3S3HGw4WChurPWdHnIxg15pZUiNzqHCg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "KmS//xA/jhFCwtvUhGxsL7oBRKDGEL61p+qhCclsCqs=",
        "OA4FehhdKA6HkQ/EvT9L/2bBpAxQ5OVzzXMkTu2/u0I="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "A6X1WDQjhaS9asDl2R6/Ewv1ze1IOX/tpYOd4Uea9h4="
    },
    {
      "name": "diverged-owner-lower-hash-wins",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5 tie rule: two owner-signed seq 2 states, X2 (adds alice) with the bytewise-lower manifestHash and Y2 (adds carol). The host holds Y2, then receives X2 and switches to it; Y2 offered again loses (manifest_conflict). alice is a member; carol, invited only on the losing chain, is not, so her push is forbidden.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "Y2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "xZ/bL7o9tAHhELIms+uaEgNX0cmv+lzAWfKHxHIimmw=",
                      "iv": "WnivnH/JA5m8lVnp",
                      "ciphertext": "MK0d+hwRgoEVvpuS1Mpvo6OCHoxO666W8yZdVS+cBppBNJmhtbvTnA4h2SSZH8J1"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "lqS0BDC/GYtsHXGyeR3ESq+M3Ox7shG16X7szrZfCAs=",
                      "iv": "pmVtIrLAdaP1/fti",
                      "ciphertext": "z0ByHjzVLQoJ/iiNfCHN2unYn1EWmBFk3bX7h2jVTP9PeketxHonCJcON5PlKMWi"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "SeYqPhWbFTH54dlFebVptpLg/3kKKzwrqGtGAw8rWcjHA6WRP5cCWPUXYNjINPjRSM2Sgb1+qHHJ4Ak5c1LgBA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "X2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "Y2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "xZ/bL7o9tAHhELIms+uaEgNX0cmv+lzAWfKHxHIimmw=",
                      "iv": "WnivnH/JA5m8lVnp",
                      "ciphertext": "MK0d+hwRgoEVvpuS1Mpvo6OCHoxO666W8yZdVS+cBppBNJmhtbvTnA4h2SSZH8J1"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "lqS0BDC/GYtsHXGyeR3ESq+M3Ox7shG16X7szrZfCAs=",
                      "iv": "pmVtIrLAdaP1/fti",
                      "ciphertext": "z0ByHjzVLQoJ/iiNfCHN2unYn1EWmBFk3bX7h2jVTP9PeketxHonCJcON5PlKMWi"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "SeYqPhWbFTH54dlFebVptpLg/3kKKzwrqGtGAw8rWcjHA6WRP5cCWPUXYNjINPjRSM2Sgb1+qHHJ4Ak5c1LgBA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "manifest_conflict"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-cites-X2",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Mil6GyYPk3E1J+45Yy9kgwqtrd45rHQFlz7m3nXmhhk=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "R+w7XGBKgKgTnyxu",
            "ciphertext": "2pZctWtM0Qh3w/HPkY/5nAtOatz/O8zo1y0Wf9jY9VtVWyb/qQ==",
            "authorSignature": "6PC/GOmV3Fi7fNaxG3sVYPiFeHfMKXfb3NAItdRtA+kNR9jhe7QvMn7ha0Iozgqmh+jPiYCkxDnXGZxxPytGAQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "c1-cites-Y2",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "z7R+D/6UlSFDAX+1ajCDyCmT/IsfrhW6YncvoQoWV68=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "7gT/Bbk9tGMiGqA+BvqcURwSkAguxVufddrm+fr5+PI=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "iv": "yn0Rr81AL+t4+Ajy",
            "ciphertext": "juyZ49BW8/cdVg2vbsVr1pSs2sjjIln0VzjGqhrI1EjWLau7/Q==",
            "authorSignature": "nzbs+GeXP3Vrdms9kwBYrMacKPKAi12YBy4bLvlYzDjjH290RhkLtTNDgLVmYjEgRyRJnTAKHfZLjU1WENnJAQ=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "Mil6GyYPk3E1J+45Yy9kgwqtrd45rHQFlz7m3nXmhhk="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "diverged-owner-higher-hash-loses",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5, 7.2: holding X2 (lower hash), the host is offered Y2: it loses the tie rule, manifest_conflict, and is retained as a verified losing state. carol's commit citing Y2 then resolves (not missing_parents) and is re-checked: X2 does not list carol and the tip epoch has not passed hers, so it is held (forbidden).",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "X2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "Y2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "xZ/bL7o9tAHhELIms+uaEgNX0cmv+lzAWfKHxHIimmw=",
                      "iv": "WnivnH/JA5m8lVnp",
                      "ciphertext": "MK0d+hwRgoEVvpuS1Mpvo6OCHoxO666W8yZdVS+cBppBNJmhtbvTnA4h2SSZH8J1"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "lqS0BDC/GYtsHXGyeR3ESq+M3Ox7shG16X7szrZfCAs=",
                      "iv": "pmVtIrLAdaP1/fti",
                      "ciphertext": "z0ByHjzVLQoJ/iiNfCHN2unYn1EWmBFk3bX7h2jVTP9PeketxHonCJcON5PlKMWi"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "SeYqPhWbFTH54dlFebVptpLg/3kKKzwrqGtGAw8rWcjHA6WRP5cCWPUXYNjINPjRSM2Sgb1+qHHJ4Ak5c1LgBA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "manifest_conflict"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "c1-cites-Y2",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "z7R+D/6UlSFDAX+1ajCDyCmT/IsfrhW6YncvoQoWV68=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "7gT/Bbk9tGMiGqA+BvqcURwSkAguxVufddrm+fr5+PI=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "iv": "yn0Rr81AL+t4+Ajy",
            "ciphertext": "juyZ49BW8/cdVg2vbsVr1pSs2sjjIln0VzjGqhrI1EjWLau7/Q==",
            "authorSignature": "nzbs+GeXP3Vrdms9kwBYrMacKPKAi12YBy4bLvlYzDjjH290RhkLtTNDgLVmYjEgRyRJnTAKHfZLjU1WENnJAQ=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [
        "z7R+D/6UlSFDAX+1ajCDyCmT/IsfrhW6YncvoQoWV68="
      ],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "diverged-owner-commit-rechecked-ok",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5: the host holds H3 (adds bob) and accepts alice's a1 citing it; then L3 (adds carol, lower hash) wins. a1 now cites a losing state and is re-checked against L3, which lists alice at the same epoch 0: it stays accepted. A new a2 citing H3 is accepted the same way.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "H3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "6Dako6l4BedkwH9VVp6krUZF7Sh0DlHJpF3xP5G3a3g=",
                      "iv": "z/CYdocZ0YSf5CQZ",
                      "ciphertext": "Kdi+05q0yoOQvLuic31+Vj1Y+UUy246PI761bB60CMRljuJ/7a3xBXUKiqyNfIoY"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "86m3BLzTCoG0ggSAi5ADxZHqPRR0goMLZDH6WuHGoVU=",
                      "iv": "yWvr3fss/pTd71h8",
                      "ciphertext": "g+GLlLbO7jzuJnbls5KB5HkqwrcmK5lkB8pg0i+7Qkrj9aQ5u+anfvmWd0GwkbEt"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "w1D/NvmGqWMsoQpCN/TXOXHlQHv8Rz0AMWeAdf3+i04=",
                      "iv": "S17ZGMFh4fhu6SC0",
                      "ciphertext": "0kAgA/DVhmedlpRbNTsN7WWdx5Iu+Dmcbsps3pjUXeoNhS9OlMEYUgU7MNEfqM2u"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "BhUyM1WaUulz/Cd4owDy/i4ui959Z5l4NGLDbHDKnGMF77Fubq1x0yMjw4IuLSGFnrgAjhN9fINIquIoI1G6Bw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-cites-H3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "ulJoApymkrmzlDicqCM3Dg1mdN1yQ/3jk/FiN3DHCkE=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "IZ3admXNbOAjN8SYW19AzIRdoz92RoFy0n87rwZDPvM=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "OkuDGkpVQtndK8gm",
            "ciphertext": "bLifNnqePHwHdZ1A+j74nsJdBQYvVhbzMZSs2yJQ5lhayGx9KQ==",
            "authorSignature": "6bEmGgWzuuhUyJ4ShrGXzd4UFk08X8KY5O4bSjVXVzVBIi9sNy6vIK2CVX2i0mzT8rJkegJtkh+B7nW1sg+2Dg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "L3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "EKVqlKhdLhYEvZQL5wTJPLgmYhVYDFWpjjJ28kjMEyI=",
                      "iv": "iSkxgnL3kgaEk67v",
                      "ciphertext": "v+ohC6/qTYbKgENbiZvh1dYBzEULt05k+cHVcub+SX1s5cdXWNenQ/4hfbqPhHN6"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "blxdeO/+S36seNewsy00Ipv+Yq2frb9+P3i3CPIyCgIV8j8qTX4cvMxIqILYc9+O25jE7rzNGbB4qUyhQ0NiBw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a2-cites-H3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Ze2m8U+61LQMPAz0ecewb8O2MLCkGe0tRcB78pAryDg=",
            "parents": [
              "ulJoApymkrmzlDicqCM3Dg1mdN1yQ/3jk/FiN3DHCkE="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "IZ3admXNbOAjN8SYW19AzIRdoz92RoFy0n87rwZDPvM=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "n+1JKG6mPz3dhJKl",
            "ciphertext": "fkdP/4zmgpRS1oJSpbngH5M+gLkUawu7q9bpGU3tAO2nB1ZDog==",
            "authorSignature": "Rd0EOnJ0NRaE+r1sAZGE5u8vQhNjqNEXweT5CqIgR866qRwLiu2j+G/l7kvofmt9QW9IsVZK4T5bB5FMJ6O0Bw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "Ze2m8U+61LQMPAz0ecewb8O2MLCkGe0tRcB78pAryDg="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "D0kuAfdgiN0zOn6wsxbWMZurMxS4yIaC6KiDVRj/E9Q="
    },
    {
      "name": "diverged-owner-commit-held",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5: one owner device removes bob (L3, epoch 1, with rotation commit rotL), the other adds carol (W3, epoch 0, lower hash). The host accepts L3, rotL, and alice's a1 at epoch 1; then W3 wins. rotL and a1 cite a losing state, W3 does not list them at epoch 1, and the tip epoch (0) has not passed theirs: they are held (rotL kept with its state, SPEC 8.3) and leave the heads. A push of a1, or of a new a2 citing L3, answers forbidden.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "L3 + rotL",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "+h+iPg3AC9z+5eCT/F8AUfSDf8fIy/pL6DX79PBdDRY=",
                      "iv": "6wxj5toVGYh6CL1i",
                      "ciphertext": "JrHOSC7f4JTCKU2aSavC3Uziat1dsOlVeMRRqBjpD1iZMlqLJyPISXhZbXpzJ7GP"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "pHn3uTVEW/GWYIBXvXAtH64oDJPqybWtWYkzPIDjYFk=",
                      "iv": "j2UGwX4ILqzBoPDK",
                      "ciphertext": "sjGEUemmua2HqCygksq5y1Poec6rxR+Gk9OqjzvijOkiq0QMzdoF1eV3LAjPxXwF"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "2sUmY+Ha6IMmVjxKbSJtW2OGKMov9B+MwoDYeSnbFzf1gDg/yjcJCH+dvIWyDkilhh5NHkmnSYsJsnsJd9VGCA=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "pnKH8mHLJX8viKdPUNWKWUQjwaWXzQGOg21KAsx/JdA=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "cgTzL4KyeyeiMFcuCJjF4R2kx59C+J8fU2X8sg6x2wk=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "LIYzeGzjZreBMT3I",
              "ciphertext": "5sryabG6UB1TCpQN2+0rcwe6x7ZK5xdbbuynIkZ751aa32KLEA==",
              "authorSignature": "DhQ0nDmixHBmJA7hhn7IWuI/fzQkxQaxb0CEEAwf2VAKgbG7+pC9XpH6X5VadRne/RRCluHdUzd7PXl/Lgu6BA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Gp96DQ/ibC6g6GcfcU3OrRXnmAJdKrrEhHFjmWYE4F0=",
            "parents": [
              "pnKH8mHLJX8viKdPUNWKWUQjwaWXzQGOg21KAsx/JdA="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "cgTzL4KyeyeiMFcuCJjF4R2kx59C+J8fU2X8sg6x2wk=",
            "keyEpoch": 1,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "m8vbT2FUQv67FFi2",
            "ciphertext": "PAQ9g1YkBJgV0fIbGRUARJvKkv7DtZTOcr9ARUFyGcq/oA9fpQ==",
            "authorSignature": "x00tkkishOtL0ZH11K1hYMhnVuxRRWzozibal305/SBU4rcxXWfayV90jo/JBYjJcIWsesAOeVQSBo3R9527AQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "W3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "EKVqlKhdLhYEvZQL5wTJPLgmYhVYDFWpjjJ28kjMEyI=",
                      "iv": "iSkxgnL3kgaEk67v",
                      "ciphertext": "v+ohC6/qTYbKgENbiZvh1dYBzEULt05k+cHVcub+SX1s5cdXWNenQ/4hfbqPhHN6"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "W+eDD8GzHQP5hPPZaIwXF2uEP3fSeM6KG5hv3W1ZSErbEgk/hi1CdH2KhAGkFkF1tpFT+WIws26himRKZvUMAw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Gp96DQ/ibC6g6GcfcU3OrRXnmAJdKrrEhHFjmWYE4F0=",
            "parents": [
              "pnKH8mHLJX8viKdPUNWKWUQjwaWXzQGOg21KAsx/JdA="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "cgTzL4KyeyeiMFcuCJjF4R2kx59C+J8fU2X8sg6x2wk=",
            "keyEpoch": 1,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "m8vbT2FUQv67FFi2",
            "ciphertext": "PAQ9g1YkBJgV0fIbGRUARJvKkv7DtZTOcr9ARUFyGcq/oA9fpQ==",
            "authorSignature": "x00tkkishOtL0ZH11K1hYMhnVuxRRWzozibal305/SBU4rcxXWfayV90jo/JBYjJcIWsesAOeVQSBo3R9527AQ=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a2-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "BcYGw6DBXf6kzSrU8+m6AGA4GNN93wSq+vhwi1VxKCo=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "cgTzL4KyeyeiMFcuCJjF4R2kx59C+J8fU2X8sg6x2wk=",
            "keyEpoch": 1,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "DpniTtii5KwuzWwi",
            "ciphertext": "30e7AIpimh2WbxHiWnWaWvkEcpjMa4zYSYSDEPIqJyLgX/5jvw==",
            "authorSignature": "+1c+VAwqpZSWtDWLdrIpswT2wPuV2DAkgEJpnYKgwPfeYQX36PyYaTwAQq4Gr+0VmtM+ym4EIReyFkBcMh41Cg=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [
        "BcYGw6DBXf6kzSrU8+m6AGA4GNN93wSq+vhwi1VxKCo=",
        "Gp96DQ/ibC6g6GcfcU3OrRXnmAJdKrrEhHFjmWYE4F0=",
        "pnKH8mHLJX8viKdPUNWKWUQjwaWXzQGOg21KAsx/JdA="
      ],
      "finalTip": "S+mnzjzWKXg007s6Ah+zrlxaWDGMZvYw9q0WcTnMWFo="
    },
    {
      "name": "held-commit-accepted-after-reinvite",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5: carol is invited only on the losing L3; her c1 citing L3 is accepted while L3 is the tip, then held when W3 (policy flip, lower hash) wins; her push is forbidden while she is not a member. W4 re-invites carol at the same epoch 0: the held c1 is re-checked against W4 and accepted.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "L3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "6Dako6l4BedkwH9VVp6krUZF7Sh0DlHJpF3xP5G3a3g=",
                      "iv": "z/CYdocZ0YSf5CQZ",
                      "ciphertext": "Kdi+05q0yoOQvLuic31+Vj1Y+UUy246PI761bB60CMRljuJ/7a3xBXUKiqyNfIoY"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "w1D/NvmGqWMsoQpCN/TXOXHlQHv8Rz0AMWeAdf3+i04=",
                      "iv": "S17ZGMFh4fhu6SC0",
                      "ciphertext": "0kAgA/DVhmedlpRbNTsN7WWdx5Iu+Dmcbsps3pjUXeoNhS9OlMEYUgU7MNEfqM2u"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Bn1+aJMMk+hc4fJaaCdI7JnlmxMXMklpnY4JHDSmwBI=",
                      "iv": "uIztAvEEIjdDecM/",
                      "ciphertext": "TSobRVWF60bZSNewEm7BlYDEvZaMiPlLkCwQUSfHTUWk1+NiSp0jNyBblvkoVeS0"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "6xRCwdFvn6Ed5oq3UEMkWiTCbdM1n/IN5ccM82EElrz8eDng5mvMC8IFD8fcF7Xd/00n2nXCqRB1EgFTzEwtCQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "c1-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "BZn8QrkkGjasN1RV2dSltm8DZx8kgTjruMKja8e1RJo=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "7tAgalMoajsi3mxX2WhDyFv2IKU5Sp+TuF6dXVhjdYg=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "iv": "WoLtWqoVAbwp4zN3",
            "ciphertext": "aLZWxXQcAKdrklyOP/aAfk8/lq4HfqBpraAFjifjGQ7/BcLLFQ==",
            "authorSignature": "YJJVuiUfN4K9SJMHrQnnJsfAHBiat/cF4kczrOtC6dDQQySkwGpiLRN6Ke9ZNXWTg5/mkiW+F0xcN02b5W3dCA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "W3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": true,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Mn4ZU3ZwKleT/zz3pz8nIeSPbvYygX6vsra4+kw8gZ/YNh4mlCpylQI3wV1RXdOot+PBL2nXGSkWbDET4yY0Bg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "c1-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "BZn8QrkkGjasN1RV2dSltm8DZx8kgTjruMKja8e1RJo=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "7tAgalMoajsi3mxX2WhDyFv2IKU5Sp+TuF6dXVhjdYg=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "iv": "WoLtWqoVAbwp4zN3",
            "ciphertext": "aLZWxXQcAKdrklyOP/aAfk8/lq4HfqBpraAFjifjGQ7/BcLLFQ==",
            "authorSignature": "YJJVuiUfN4K9SJMHrQnnJsfAHBiat/cF4kczrOtC6dDQQySkwGpiLRN6Ke9ZNXWTg5/mkiW+F0xcN02b5W3dCA=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "W4",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 4,
                "prevManifestHash": "y+VhzDkFs+Ij085ZYnW2ZHGd5cC5aDmtcZuu6M+hxHI=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": true,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "EKVqlKhdLhYEvZQL5wTJPLgmYhVYDFWpjjJ28kjMEyI=",
                      "iv": "iSkxgnL3kgaEk67v",
                      "ciphertext": "v+ohC6/qTYbKgENbiZvh1dYBzEULt05k+cHVcub+SX1s5cdXWNenQ/4hfbqPhHN6"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "9wxcwJPE/qukmX1uVSN/sFSHbx9rO3XQEgIc8SiZb1ULyGsIbHtObMooFi3uXkJu5fE3F0ACsXHh1+VA+/YYCg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "BZn8QrkkGjasN1RV2dSltm8DZx8kgTjruMKja8e1RJo="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "NwgHYqSf8uEKHkkUX/4fRchyRYKROaFDPtqsiYBjClk="
    },
    {
      "name": "held-commit-dropped-after-epoch",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5: carol's c1 and its child c2 cite the losing L3; when W3 (lower hash) wins they are held. W4 removes bob and raises the epoch to 1: re-checked against W4, c1 meets the drop test (tip epoch 1 exceeds its 0) and is dropped permanently, c2 with it. Offering c1 again is forbidden, and a new c3 citing L3 meets the drop test at its first classification: forbidden.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "L3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "6Dako6l4BedkwH9VVp6krUZF7Sh0DlHJpF3xP5G3a3g=",
                      "iv": "z/CYdocZ0YSf5CQZ",
                      "ciphertext": "Kdi+05q0yoOQvLuic31+Vj1Y+UUy246PI761bB60CMRljuJ/7a3xBXUKiqyNfIoY"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "86m3BLzTCoG0ggSAi5ADxZHqPRR0goMLZDH6WuHGoVU=",
                      "iv": "yWvr3fss/pTd71h8",
                      "ciphertext": "g+GLlLbO7jzuJnbls5KB5HkqwrcmK5lkB8pg0i+7Qkrj9aQ5u+anfvmWd0GwkbEt"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "w1D/NvmGqWMsoQpCN/TXOXHlQHv8Rz0AMWeAdf3+i04=",
                      "iv": "S17ZGMFh4fhu6SC0",
                      "ciphertext": "0kAgA/DVhmedlpRbNTsN7WWdx5Iu+Dmcbsps3pjUXeoNhS9OlMEYUgU7MNEfqM2u"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Bn1+aJMMk+hc4fJaaCdI7JnlmxMXMklpnY4JHDSmwBI=",
                      "iv": "uIztAvEEIjdDecM/",
                      "ciphertext": "TSobRVWF60bZSNewEm7BlYDEvZaMiPlLkCwQUSfHTUWk1+NiSp0jNyBblvkoVeS0"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "+tnyUliWnq0EarX2Dfp0+drGxRiFXng1a0nvDjb1U4NFt8LVEEk6SBHah+pNIa11HdduCK1Qq7tclw0WwgoiDw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "c1-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "lrerCI2V4EySpB26D6KunjDycCW90aWelAmOwOEs71U=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "dz8gAcLQgF1G6WKrwhbPM5dmve3LRElet+VYeGTaA78=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "iv": "WoLtWqoVAbwp4zN3",
            "ciphertext": "aLZWxXQcAKdrklyOP/aAfk8/lq4HfqBpraAFjifjGQ7/BcLLFQ==",
            "authorSignature": "RaS4xbWgacEHcADjoU1OT42VFFm3KcVkGVVF/C1IdHs342S+JIsryk/8v/2lK7DTc4QrbfdmUnIUBkuXaf9zDA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "c2-child-of-c1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "jhgWBo986sodwbtZSdmVFWkzQ8n7DrtfMp4nRF4cxi0=",
            "parents": [
              "lrerCI2V4EySpB26D6KunjDycCW90aWelAmOwOEs71U="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "dz8gAcLQgF1G6WKrwhbPM5dmve3LRElet+VYeGTaA78=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "iv": "4hh0nE6IEHt2X8X0",
            "ciphertext": "2FY5ZD99uTvP4sEJ6uFrflhbvZzeZ7igmkbz84f6qRQ8R6fSBA==",
            "authorSignature": "3dq1VilytfLbgUUBJTpzOzkuWlO/e0sLMzt8EzYMJLxMCeN2Y6oagVVJEFXLjLPhXd2KTIPtpiHM+eGg9sBqDw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "W3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": true,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Za+ZGW6TY+8QZQOs4chTswtXvFf51xrEyobpqfzYGaxY6AdWBF6IyC3sWm+o2ZfO1Ybr/s9wwdDf9YZX3dW/Cg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "W4 + rot4",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 4,
                "prevManifestHash": "Ib8ie8pwXRB0n01sAGdNPurORPdeZdXyqQjGOp6vncg=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": true,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 4,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "IWiUzCkLxQb2N+7GCjO96La6d9X2r5C0RB11z9eQAsuY0IiShBws08o7DhBZLkQOlBXLe/hSXbX3cbKcymx+DQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "ojwSyTOhvSwm0XXiua4eDjY8OFKtSoZ1VIz05VWkz9c=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 4,
              "manifestHash": "y2BL4ZC7uf7wgHfWrmJT9SZjkK0rJ5GmynsmTpQ9O3U=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "/aNvpPkr2Zd12ksR",
              "ciphertext": "NGYDpRR44MQ9yCiaUSbav4eEyu6Rvim4Fo0RadvAyqCMNhVYHw==",
              "authorSignature": "FupBFpOlkPTwaLMdTQ0cTflA1j6aHTaBYajNrCVBY1+o/eQGZ95/H91NXdJ0kh5QApFyoC7XGC0Dv9Rzlf5PAw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "c1-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "lrerCI2V4EySpB26D6KunjDycCW90aWelAmOwOEs71U=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "dz8gAcLQgF1G6WKrwhbPM5dmve3LRElet+VYeGTaA78=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "iv": "WoLtWqoVAbwp4zN3",
            "ciphertext": "aLZWxXQcAKdrklyOP/aAfk8/lq4HfqBpraAFjifjGQ7/BcLLFQ==",
            "authorSignature": "RaS4xbWgacEHcADjoU1OT42VFFm3KcVkGVVF/C1IdHs342S+JIsryk/8v/2lK7DTc4QrbfdmUnIUBkuXaf9zDA=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "c3-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "4lpQkLz75CwKxhCUtIOadfiFrp0/4TTTeBpidZ/S4cg=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "dz8gAcLQgF1G6WKrwhbPM5dmve3LRElet+VYeGTaA78=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "iv": "uH7EAbNIpHFCw6Lz",
            "ciphertext": "0SgUZvsyZvKQ7TZKcONvVt4Ci/UUBE+4IEmEKuzMtiQwYNfDuQ==",
            "authorSignature": "o7xTfxZGKJeILB+G1c2xvWOGcRhVgDhn+liYs/fVglt40nJ2LUndx/JX6vrTjvZvSAwShyHfxyamnyURH1apDg=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "ojwSyTOhvSwm0XXiua4eDjY8OFKtSoZ1VIz05VWkz9c="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "y2BL4ZC7uf7wgHfWrmJT9SZjkK0rJ5GmynsmTpQ9O3U="
    },
    {
      "name": "leave-bad-signature",
      "description": "SPEC 8.4: a leave request for alice whose signature is bob's: it does not verify under memberKey, bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "leave",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "alice-leave-signed-by-bob",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "memberKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "at": 1767229200000,
            "signature": "kDEEGLA/qvB73Re+fioneA4FhLsqYX1CLtix8aOdEYGKriYrWu+i3FjCdnu5PR2tMBVuyOLgSkq0HH95x79RDQ=="
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "leave-ok",
      "description": "SPEC 8.4: alice, a member of the tip and not the owner, publishes a validly signed leave request: accepted.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "leave",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "alice-leave",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "memberKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "at": 1767229200000,
            "signature": "GRAXN/+3DMbFRA+cW4nj8Uwp4kZR0+EnT4QJgGsMkLoryog3dZbjo3QJ9olbWYXsvV8b1yaunk1uAfMT3D6nAg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "leave-non-member",
      "description": "SPEC 8.4: carol, not a member of the tip, publishes a validly signed leave request: forbidden.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "leave",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "carol-leave",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "memberKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "at": 1767229200000,
            "signature": "ZMEPvUitwnsz3DldT6P1aiN3cKoeLEqZCsVWb/GYuZFxRA+seDS47qPrmOiHR7YWh5UYJOJd/npX0N8bCvxMAA=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "leave-owner",
      "description": "SPEC 8.4: the owner cannot leave its own repository: forbidden.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "leave",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "owner-leave",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "memberKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
            "at": 1767229200000,
            "signature": "KVZXdWTazvjDTD+TCi3gf9WIO55cGdCnMiyNiBtwGNRwY1qiQIxjs+wNahdjY7xSDWddKpzWzUU+Y7wsfPa2DQ=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "removed-member-undecided-then-dropped",
      "description": "SPEC 7.3: bob's b3 is accepted while bob is a member. seq 3 removes bob with frontier {a1, b1, b2}; b2 is unknown, so the host cannot decide b3 and MUST NOT keep accepting it (it leaves the heads, undecided, not dropped). b0 and b2 arrive (each first missing_parents); once b2's verified header is known, the frontier's ancestry is complete, b3 is neither in it nor an ancestor of it, and b3 is dropped. b0 and b2 are then accepted.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "NBKmJpxb1+aVBlmZ+w9zfRzrifgxeTPFs8FYr54VTZr+5ofVcIUStwyeCJ1c2HrmPjLBWDLHK3TiyW60t6nYAg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "ja7DPQSFiSKcH8/P",
            "ciphertext": "LCwZLe1snwQHUL00n9nTotPVnv4uv5wI4NrxeswHPKDMlBSTqg==",
            "authorSignature": "ZSzcMthK/wLlICIQskYQusscst9+emsKrMGQtg6SFhBPMkap5ud1e33eyDzSNLmxT05LhbNSK4n38wgJrUobCg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b3-after-cutoff",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "8xskwTqODNV7/Mcejgs7ynxLSIkUb8sUAegqSO3FVwA=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "sDku3IriuGv9ZNR3",
            "ciphertext": "5vvV89f6HVXrDYUhcDXNldlWnEqffeed9J+15/NU+8LO5Up2mw==",
            "authorSignature": "1Aaeyzjsax8WJnb0+TvhjXFn1mCSidvywW74VlXA+fIYwn4RruoExVlEJIkHIpgaEv8+U3qWObNjg6A3c9iZAA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
                      "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
                      "TbkspYmn4R/mXzIhJf2TFihYYv/jPN8FKuGtAAugB+w="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "6dcTeBZ14k6x5g75hHy5dvODqk5/lN7uxSSJKmEyGuNPJyZYusaRIRISTH+0Ix/oZc7bSr4sWQnRkbrYWWQlAw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "2ASdG62vUEn/Fxm7AXm3nCV3PuScjDLzqLMlVCk9I68=",
              "parents": [
                "4tGE417VidwUVnGSdFThvV/g+R+9U0jbmUE0Plhgvhs=",
                "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "qwThlLaTH99+roexljFa8C0Ubt5v8x0s2tadIx388ZQ=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JvWulNZs5gpJXSS2",
              "ciphertext": "lU6AXvJAJkg/57Xwx9EUmrZFegP9+yCLpWpThG1/E4I/z7kC0w==",
              "authorSignature": "eKQ2Zz0/aCHJ8WI32/Y9H6YyUXr8DbMvF3nHfW5wAvhff4lDzagtGarKPxAUfShy4EIR+4cCyMw5N90Z3W8UAA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b0",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "g1n5B32bi3vq3pQ0LXs0I9xkWixHMkjbzKy3WxAntFk=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "TwTDpsYBoai+1J4x",
            "ciphertext": "na9kai6qsBKO6ADorxbC3lhu1x9FTwvUO0VEtnwLqFVq2w2EmQ==",
            "authorSignature": "pvNhqRXiSLUfzMnsq/ftQTB+ERqSFjNGr/C3CSaWKMWuLx6y6OKIg910tZSe8ZghGrkBoFXJfO3aB65R+BWVDw=="
          },
          "expect": "missing_parents"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b2-child-of-b0",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "TbkspYmn4R/mXzIhJf2TFihYYv/jPN8FKuGtAAugB+w=",
            "parents": [
              "g1n5B32bi3vq3pQ0LXs0I9xkWixHMkjbzKy3WxAntFk="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "5/5kheNZqVhfgLer",
            "ciphertext": "YS6KpCJ7tqQSuDYIo92xe+aFj99gBU+w9apIN1nLhfC0Bx0isQ==",
            "authorSignature": "Qh967slOL40bTQIu37mCbOZ/kWjkh/X71U/lnWggDSboQWuT1KQdNfTPppcGH4uC7sbv316DPLwRb3LeWvQ/CQ=="
          },
          "expect": "missing_parents"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b0",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "g1n5B32bi3vq3pQ0LXs0I9xkWixHMkjbzKy3WxAntFk=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "TwTDpsYBoai+1J4x",
            "ciphertext": "na9kai6qsBKO6ADorxbC3lhu1x9FTwvUO0VEtnwLqFVq2w2EmQ==",
            "authorSignature": "pvNhqRXiSLUfzMnsq/ftQTB+ERqSFjNGr/C3CSaWKMWuLx6y6OKIg910tZSe8ZghGrkBoFXJfO3aB65R+BWVDw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b2-child-of-b0",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "TbkspYmn4R/mXzIhJf2TFihYYv/jPN8FKuGtAAugB+w=",
            "parents": [
              "g1n5B32bi3vq3pQ0LXs0I9xkWixHMkjbzKy3WxAntFk="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "5/5kheNZqVhfgLer",
            "ciphertext": "YS6KpCJ7tqQSuDYIo92xe+aFj99gBU+w9apIN1nLhfC0Bx0isQ==",
            "authorSignature": "Qh967slOL40bTQIu37mCbOZ/kWjkh/X71U/lnWggDSboQWuT1KQdNfTPppcGH4uC7sbv316DPLwRb3LeWvQ/CQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "2ASdG62vUEn/Fxm7AXm3nCV3PuScjDLzqLMlVCk9I68=",
        "TbkspYmn4R/mXzIhJf2TFihYYv/jPN8FKuGtAAugB+w="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "qwThlLaTH99+roexljFa8C0Ubt5v8x0s2tadIx388ZQ="
    },
    {
      "name": "removed-member-undecided-held-kept",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5, 7.3: holding W3, the host is offered the losing L3 (epoch 1) with its rotation commit rotL, which is kept held (SPEC 8.3); alice's a2 citing L3 at epoch 1 is held. W4 removes alice (epoch 1) with frontier {x}, a commit this host never saw. Deciding the held commits against W4: rotL meets no drop test and W4 lists the owner at epoch 1, so it is accepted; for a2 the cutoff cannot be decided without x, so a2 is neither accepted (W4 does not list alice) nor dropped: it stays held.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "W3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "EKVqlKhdLhYEvZQL5wTJPLgmYhVYDFWpjjJ28kjMEyI=",
                      "iv": "iSkxgnL3kgaEk67v",
                      "ciphertext": "v+ohC6/qTYbKgENbiZvh1dYBzEULt05k+cHVcub+SX1s5cdXWNenQ/4hfbqPhHN6"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "W+eDD8GzHQP5hPPZaIwXF2uEP3fSeM6KG5hv3W1ZSErbEgk/hi1CdH2KhAGkFkF1tpFT+WIws26himRKZvUMAw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "L3 + rotL",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "+h+iPg3AC9z+5eCT/F8AUfSDf8fIy/pL6DX79PBdDRY=",
                      "iv": "6wxj5toVGYh6CL1i",
                      "ciphertext": "JrHOSC7f4JTCKU2aSavC3Uziat1dsOlVeMRRqBjpD1iZMlqLJyPISXhZbXpzJ7GP"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "pHn3uTVEW/GWYIBXvXAtH64oDJPqybWtWYkzPIDjYFk=",
                      "iv": "j2UGwX4ILqzBoPDK",
                      "ciphertext": "sjGEUemmua2HqCygksq5y1Poec6rxR+Gk9OqjzvijOkiq0QMzdoF1eV3LAjPxXwF"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "2sUmY+Ha6IMmVjxKbSJtW2OGKMov9B+MwoDYeSnbFzf1gDg/yjcJCH+dvIWyDkilhh5NHkmnSYsJsnsJd9VGCA=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "pnKH8mHLJX8viKdPUNWKWUQjwaWXzQGOg21KAsx/JdA=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "cgTzL4KyeyeiMFcuCJjF4R2kx59C+J8fU2X8sg6x2wk=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "LIYzeGzjZreBMT3I",
              "ciphertext": "5sryabG6UB1TCpQN2+0rcwe6x7ZK5xdbbuynIkZ751aa32KLEA==",
              "authorSignature": "DhQ0nDmixHBmJA7hhn7IWuI/fzQkxQaxb0CEEAwf2VAKgbG7+pC9XpH6X5VadRne/RRCluHdUzd7PXl/Lgu6BA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "manifest_conflict"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a2-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "BcYGw6DBXf6kzSrU8+m6AGA4GNN93wSq+vhwi1VxKCo=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "cgTzL4KyeyeiMFcuCJjF4R2kx59C+J8fU2X8sg6x2wk=",
            "keyEpoch": 1,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "DpniTtii5KwuzWwi",
            "ciphertext": "30e7AIpimh2WbxHiWnWaWvkEcpjMa4zYSYSDEPIqJyLgX/5jvw==",
            "authorSignature": "+1c+VAwqpZSWtDWLdrIpswT2wPuV2DAkgEJpnYKgwPfeYQX36PyYaTwAQq4Gr+0VmtM+ym4EIReyFkBcMh41Cg=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "W4 + rot4",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 4,
                "prevManifestHash": "S+mnzjzWKXg007s6Ah+zrlxaWDGMZvYw9q0WcTnMWFo=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "ccNbfofkQR5alrMgURlEK0sIahoecor46Mwvb5ui2z8=",
                      "iv": "aQF3rMEMaCbn+0L+",
                      "ciphertext": "K3i2w5EAs3pZyfcAS41VJdA5+d74LhH23Q6DiGSDA3ROEklfbTsnYTL7iDNyVUs4"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "bNJl6+PMz54/w/tY6YNQvfmVq1pDki1Zz523KJHrX2g=",
                      "iv": "XoTW3J/jyI7M23h9",
                      "ciphertext": "67dH1gICrs0sodRuSMJkLIize1clc4cP8SbcDqsH+LgDxXwVKWnW8LDtrlrHx7oA"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 4,
                    "frontier": [
                      "DM2bTXm0aupOkJExsde4f9sv1hE1nWsq8Au8/SZ7Uc4="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "1aklrzhKMsujNhE9vI565xESfO9kqOhr7EAbRifXO1zcJrTaSkGIkov7YqvthAQPVC1vFN4WX51BK9K6KLOzAw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "7QLOPLZfryxGqTV/1wV8hYBtda/PiYRRYhj39KiB78U=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 4,
              "manifestHash": "hIAXGkH7hohs8SSxt3GTup6LVPSh2XIXmLB57KlExUg=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "/aNvpPkr2Zd12ksR",
              "ciphertext": "NGYDpRR44MQ9yCiaUSbav4eEyu6Rvim4Fo0RadvAyqCMNhVYHw==",
              "authorSignature": "6yAN/GhEXIOlYJPpgCxVlgveNzpRRf5aPeds4o/1YhcA3awujhZHF+1pAy3yMj2Z8TpRaswyEtJOT7/s6D9mDQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "7QLOPLZfryxGqTV/1wV8hYBtda/PiYRRYhj39KiB78U=",
        "pnKH8mHLJX8viKdPUNWKWUQjwaWXzQGOg21KAsx/JdA="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [
        "BcYGw6DBXf6kzSrU8+m6AGA4GNN93wSq+vhwi1VxKCo="
      ],
      "finalTip": "hIAXGkH7hohs8SSxt3GTup6LVPSh2XIXmLB57KlExUg="
    },
    {
      "name": "diverged-owner-publish-needs-tip-plus-one",
      "description": "SPEC 6.3, 6.5: holding Y2 (adds carol), the host gets a client publish of X2 (adds alice), whose manifestHash is lower. A host accepts a state from a client only at tip + 1 linked to the tip, so the publish is manifest_conflict and the tip stays Y2 (X2 is kept as a verified losing state). The same X2 by replication wins the tie rule and becomes the tip.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "Y2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "xZ/bL7o9tAHhELIms+uaEgNX0cmv+lzAWfKHxHIimmw=",
                      "iv": "WnivnH/JA5m8lVnp",
                      "ciphertext": "MK0d+hwRgoEVvpuS1Mpvo6OCHoxO666W8yZdVS+cBppBNJmhtbvTnA4h2SSZH8J1"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "lqS0BDC/GYtsHXGyeR3ESq+M3Ox7shG16X7szrZfCAs=",
                      "iv": "pmVtIrLAdaP1/fti",
                      "ciphertext": "z0ByHjzVLQoJ/iiNfCHN2unYn1EWmBFk3bX7h2jVTP9PeketxHonCJcON5PlKMWi"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "SeYqPhWbFTH54dlFebVptpLg/3kKKzwrqGtGAw8rWcjHA6WRP5cCWPUXYNjINPjRSM2Sgb1+qHHJ4Ak5c1LgBA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "X2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "manifest_conflict"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "X2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "genesis-without-commit",
      "description": "SPEC 8.2, 10.4: createRepo carries the genesis state and its first commit, accepted together or not at all; a client publish of the genesis without the commit is a malformed request: bad_request, nothing stored.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": null
    },
    {
      "name": "content-hosts-empty",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: hosts is not empty; this state lists no host. The seq 2 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "csO+dQWyAbpVkMOY0V/vV8jLncLV4je4Rn3ndGOMlhdTFoNRtIKRQdLL+K4ot27Wv0kTUMGIoefMvkCr+54ODQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-owner-not-member",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: members contains exactly one entry whose ed25519PublicKey equals ownerKey; this state lists only alice. The seq 2 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "M1HrdPdZPLrEvcDThknbt7ssETrm8mDDxgH36J80wKzAZgJCp2CjDZ5cE1JmypMZ87Hm8FdU78Yqcwe4gyY9AA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-member-epoch-mismatch",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: every member's keyEpoch equals the state's keyEpoch; alice's entry says 1 in an epoch 0 state. The seq 2 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "nr3CB+4mDy4LkYLmwuFhKQUQTDbDUg/cQlhf2yV1KC5XCiHhpA3EdnriZhC8SBF6WjU41qHGeWnZ1NypVPIvBg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-home-host-not-listed",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: every member's homeHostKey equals the hostKey of an entry in hosts; alice's home is c.vault.example, which is not listed. The seq 2 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "W5Q3rer/vo9BsT2W7UnS9RzWwmbNjswoSwVS7EkSuN0="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "PDKUP119NiVTG5r9pUd8d6bcap1wXJJLfJxGxTagwJlQMtHqjRLawHHIFUvaRCUGkaQbeHZnAuMMOePGCPdeAQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-repo-id-changed",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: repoId is unchanged from the previous state; this one names another repository. The seq 2 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "ndV4hcP0XHhIOjCt8XXhrg",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "TjBbctP/0MTeb57VuD/IetqcxP400V58BtPqqAv+Klf7RWgyflV7paUVHjkF1kgYPBGR8JLypKI1LyU7lF2+CQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-owner-key-changed",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: ownerKey is unchanged from the previous state; this one, signed by alice, names alice as ownerKey. The seq 2 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "xbzA20DVlgCACYQ0SnJDujTMUn2axTORwx0jdT8bn8Sbhpnus62Ui42xFbQljdmdejSQQzBz+W6Vd91U1g10Dg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-scheme-id-changed",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: schemeId is unchanged from the previous state. The seq 2 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v2",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "QAIosp4ChjckO3U+tIgaKv55BQ0vKHV3vg50wlPDKOWRVCLOyyfNQwYYBsyq34cdN6sriHLPWGueeEiYVQDRCw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-genesis-nonce-after-seq-1",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: genesisNonce is empty after seq 1 (also a rule 1 length); this seq 2 state repeats the 16-byte nonce. The seq 2 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "LZklwzTPsqbe7FnQ0KwhiYm/lyxx7EvGEBBy07kg327epjixN3OtWvDMg18KJnbeghK7lESboh7Gyv50LRwKBA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-epoch-jump-2",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: keyEpoch equals the previous keyEpoch or the previous keyEpoch + 1; this state jumps from 0 to 2. The seq 2 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 2,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "WHY5gK8BLC07F/VWneFVy4zaOUcuZxCWeycDoyPOgUc=",
                      "iv": "caOra/YBfl/qt16D",
                      "ciphertext": "fJQzftp47X6rdIdQk41y3KQm+pj7opDyxj67x6VquQTfsXsSOzIzb9/fgINKbQxH"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 2,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "JN4tVgpCdJRugxtItUfoz6nicwFgUGSvzchlRlc9PUs=",
                      "iv": "lilvhxUDc0jIRsk1",
                      "ciphertext": "8MSO1kJLlEuA3Gj8QOIw/kaXvRR27o7KD1snTxG7885LdE0ywpwQw+r6zo9chgtA"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 2,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "x8TEPefE2pv61rxxNCKbxGvEUTHhkmxl9gsPiNcgYeaO+MzOJm8U+sAiPbKVvXVQLiUB6vjwDu5sJTyjVT3pDQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-removed-key-still-member",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: no member's ed25519PublicKey equals the memberKey of any removal; bob is removed and still listed. The seq 3 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "ccNbfofkQR5alrMgURlEK0sIahoecor46Mwvb5ui2z8=",
                      "iv": "aQF3rMEMaCbn+0L+",
                      "ciphertext": "K3i2w5EAs3pZyfcAS41VJdA5+d74LhH23Q6DiGSDA3ROEklfbTsnYTL7iDNyVUs4"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "2cDVD2+iWN6VLbOA6vp4SAPLEGB/sBlE8Jnk6DgQaWmy6q91Ol/LDFaoFZif0UThrf2Sp9fsIruSa06Spc3CDQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-removed-at-seq-out-of-range",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: every removal's removedAtSeq is at most the state's manifestSeq, and a new removal's equals it; bob's says 4 in a seq 3 state. The seq 3 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 4,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "F2SJqQ8I1moc3653MBdz5ASDbwRP5kVpOC0yfKBQn5sxet4dS4dVk4BMa9cIJ46Op0VQJPY1b74IFuJZUH30BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-new-removal-of-non-member",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: every new removal names a key that was a member of the previous state; carol never was. The seq 3 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "ccNbfofkQR5alrMgURlEK0sIahoecor46Mwvb5ui2z8=",
                      "iv": "aQF3rMEMaCbn+0L+",
                      "ciphertext": "K3i2w5EAs3pZyfcAS41VJdA5+d74LhH23Q6DiGSDA3ROEklfbTsnYTL7iDNyVUs4"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "iddqtAQ/4E7nhQW9v7W3tumJ3HpAwCYTqSRjnJhOtOrA9RqZofRc+hg4VEO12/gAblbXjrJ7im+D5rHnCfb6CA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-owner-removed",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: ownerKey is never removed (and members contains the owner exactly once); this state removes the owner. The seq 3 state is validly signed and links to the tip, so the content rule decides: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3-bad",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "ccNbfofkQR5alrMgURlEK0sIahoecor46Mwvb5ui2z8=",
                      "iv": "aQF3rMEMaCbn+0L+",
                      "ciphertext": "K3i2w5EAs3pZyfcAS41VJdA5+d74LhH23Q6DiGSDA3ROEklfbTsnYTL7iDNyVUs4"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "sAsK1GHLSmypGDFliJhp7Y+eOXFh9iOKxCDTGehwjGM9yqm1VwYZKtvVEi/wCmigkSurg/S8NJ9HyT/6tcv8DA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-earlier-removal-altered",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: every removal of the previous state appears unchanged (memberKey, removedAtSeq, and frontier); seq 4 repeats bob's removal with an empty frontier: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "aIx2pt4lP3Y3wSWtuzHtCLpsnYVw4XlhgWVPJOc5zuQlny3KVg+Z820IHmJ0iDQvnnYbnQvKtT75xNA2ln4kDw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "UidzS/j8L2ZLh8v5foloSNlUfZz1+WIJyol1XOC90zQ=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JvWulNZs5gpJXSS2",
              "ciphertext": "lU6AXvJAJkg/57Xwx9EUmrZFegP9QwcgW6+5QdoGVGBf1vS2Nw==",
              "authorSignature": "bOJu/Ika0LN+9gKXPvxHU3COk2Nmp44hSnzPH7Dmj4jiafOjcKVbPxr6Nism4k6O0dSM+qxaqob7mGaZv0L0Bw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M4-altered-removal",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 4,
                "prevManifestHash": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": []
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Yp63iStJSYH+74rxlrA9i0tLIBBYNqyhWA6EBne9kWFYICTY3Qz3n1l0MaR/tjiQbMKuNFcKYsDD038a2KN4Cg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "UidzS/j8L2ZLh8v5foloSNlUfZz1+WIJyol1XOC90zQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ="
    },
    {
      "name": "content-earlier-removal-omitted",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 5: removals are cumulative, every removal of the previous state appears unchanged; seq 4 drops bob's removal: bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "aIx2pt4lP3Y3wSWtuzHtCLpsnYVw4XlhgWVPJOc5zuQlny3KVg+Z820IHmJ0iDQvnnYbnQvKtT75xNA2ln4kDw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "UidzS/j8L2ZLh8v5foloSNlUfZz1+WIJyol1XOC90zQ=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JvWulNZs5gpJXSS2",
              "ciphertext": "lU6AXvJAJkg/57Xwx9EUmrZFegP9QwcgW6+5QdoGVGBf1vS2Nw==",
              "authorSignature": "bOJu/Ika0LN+9gKXPvxHU3COk2Nmp44hSnzPH7Dmj4jiafOjcKVbPxr6Nism4k6O0dSM+qxaqob7mGaZv0L0Bw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M4-omits-removal",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 4,
                "prevManifestHash": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "km4sJ8ttDPMs0WVtWl4i5c9fqGefBJoMn1djxEWcTWXhaUZpbycedvTb+17BaPK27Z+LK5Qybg8mPbidhse7BA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "UidzS/j8L2ZLh8v5foloSNlUfZz1+WIJyol1XOC90zQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ="
    },
    {
      "name": "genesis-epoch-not-zero",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 3, 6.2: the genesis state MUST have keyEpoch 0; this one has 1: bad_request, nothing stored.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G-bad + r-genesis-epoch-not-zero",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "9WgIQmeZVmI1yGNFlqc2k3Q1CCTq9Z/sq/TLUyE0Pw9Ob8VG5URePrNkVk1+1MCSlIoMSCTw2Hkspt4V3dE/CQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "SrxNyjqSTLUsfIZ1XdYokwKANUTqU4PWV98b0Iqg3NE=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "+Kt7tb8ga7Nbye3ESQELMnuvBKcp2Pd86yBVFHN9BFc=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "jScfE7NJMBRUmYUH",
              "ciphertext": "Mzi+LtsZK6TCruUo/pyu3OdktN5fiWlEvVE2plH7Aky96culOg==",
              "authorSignature": "D3JO1CfwrrOiP+dGSTFFGQLtSvyiqkMwI2ObTqaj0zOtwBzzaaJoOVp5jOL6hWUC9IMduFG+q4Whk4fKcL05Bw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": null
    },
    {
      "name": "genesis-extra-member",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 3, 6.2: the genesis state MUST have exactly one member, the owner; this one also lists alice: bad_request, nothing stored.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G-bad + r-genesis-extra-member",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "i2DIpsgGGNlpX9OgrHFGeP2YcPluwZIudhyhm1u7MKMoPnvPj9Nb7l7QgRjCK6Kz6OaYh8+vF+zGy5webCx8Aw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "Hr+CYYiU+SYNotxv/ovuCh3Qe0FiPT/irxBycMQSLLs=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "H2ENNACAsVA7vMfVIbuGwX1aKbskqdMhTNZ0QzjUNYk=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "wApZS5qaCc/G9v2m",
              "ciphertext": "XGbFMqxGGz15w4hZKMHDnrgmdI5vwtXbjFHjWjNc7indU/Ejdw==",
              "authorSignature": "rGKUpuAke3Tx+IUZ1p48rpwAWt9cGEwswvgSbgYQCWfmv7kGe5Ce5HLwi6kIEE3bhnihAU7IlI/w3izDZh3OBA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": null
    },
    {
      "name": "genesis-with-removals",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 3, 6.2: the genesis state MUST have no removals; this one removes bob: bad_request, nothing stored.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G-bad + r-genesis-with-removals",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 1,
                    "frontier": []
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "S7EuyBTcyQavc8si/fk3UmLbhbkDrC+wBH5j++E18cyu/cpG2UJymPucSnE/mYTe6V59tGY6LeyfEs+3VBdXDg=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "F0PzvrhCFK1znTwDcVrBv0gGMWygpnlHyAa6ewagaUY=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "3lu7LmgYqcUPKN2zwRBUwlPjauP9zwSBHHpMLC3l3TU=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "L65AvWQSIVoNPenb",
              "ciphertext": "b2dCmS1fOWMoY6TEaxbDWT6o5mcWXonxmKnGAErZrJgZaWZYrA==",
              "authorSignature": "YSX0To2XhUEG2Um1ne31KAZOBRYyl5S8Q3+CYakN6GcjsiBnofid4G5p95Z8g8sVcfcXOlRzYBR1oVUUpVrNDg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": null
    },
    {
      "name": "manifest-drops-this-host",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 6, 8.6: a valid seq 2 state lists only b.vault.example (the owner's home moved to b); at a.vault.example it is not_hosted and the tip stays at genesis.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-hosts-b-only",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "T33cCQRu/wDnRtewHOmJrvOtlJ8EaV8YkFX/Y2mtQ+pkdg5AlpArnokwF/Vxm2F7gxSy0M4JMRgvDdmNnr1fDQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "not_hosted"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0="
    },
    {
      "name": "manifest-malformed-structure",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 1, 4.2: a seq 2 state with a host listed twice, a wrappedDataKey ciphertext of 47 bytes (not 48), a 63-byte ownerSignature, or a 31-byte prevManifestHash is malformed: bad_request each; the intact state is then accepted.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-duplicate-host",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-wrap-47-bytes",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb4="
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-signature-63-bytes",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39O"
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-prev-hash-31-bytes",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRA==",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "commit-malformed-structure",
      "description": "SPEC 7.1, 4.3: a commit listing the same parent twice, with an 11-byte iv, a 63-byte authorSignature, or a 15-byte ciphertext (shorter than the GCM tag) is malformed: bad_request each; the intact commit is then accepted.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-duplicate-parent",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "jlrY7XR71fm7hGRvbFttoQGC5YITXLMlTDQZYTmt8QLYvhynpVAsv2mEnUo4DtpbxoPX5Bjzforjvrwb+e1rBA=="
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-iv-11-bytes",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPc=",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "jlrY7XR71fm7hGRvbFttoQGC5YITXLMlTDQZYTmt8QLYvhynpVAsv2mEnUo4DtpbxoPX5Bjzforjvrwb+e1rBA=="
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-signature-63-bytes",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "jlrY7XR71fm7hGRvbFttoQGC5YITXLMlTDQZYTmt8QLYvhynpVAsv2mEnUo4DtpbxoPX5Bjzforjvrwb+e1r"
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-ciphertext-15-bytes",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGd",
            "authorSignature": "jlrY7XR71fm7hGRvbFttoQGC5YITXLMlTDQZYTmt8QLYvhynpVAsv2mEnUo4DtpbxoPX5Bjzforjvrwb+e1rBA=="
          },
          "expect": "bad_request"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "dKSlzHMBYjM3wPeP",
            "ciphertext": "yu5q+YOfl95ORBzd1wGdgYnxX2MWEZ39wbwIQxhgKZLQ7QstNA==",
            "authorSignature": "jlrY7XR71fm7hGRvbFttoQGC5YITXLMlTDQZYTmt8QLYvhynpVAsv2mEnUo4DtpbxoPX5Bjzforjvrwb+e1rBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "HmVeuc+ax2xtiSFjFrYlqVi7ccsf5C4x6Txo+sdG75c="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "commit-with-held-parent-held",
      "description": "SPEC 7.4, 6.5: as in diverged-owner-commit-held, rotL and a1 are held once W3 wins. alice's a3 cites the winning W3 correctly (member, epoch 0) but its parent a1 is held, so a3 is held too: forbidden.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "L3 + rotL",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "+h+iPg3AC9z+5eCT/F8AUfSDf8fIy/pL6DX79PBdDRY=",
                      "iv": "6wxj5toVGYh6CL1i",
                      "ciphertext": "JrHOSC7f4JTCKU2aSavC3Uziat1dsOlVeMRRqBjpD1iZMlqLJyPISXhZbXpzJ7GP"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "pHn3uTVEW/GWYIBXvXAtH64oDJPqybWtWYkzPIDjYFk=",
                      "iv": "j2UGwX4ILqzBoPDK",
                      "ciphertext": "sjGEUemmua2HqCygksq5y1Poec6rxR+Gk9OqjzvijOkiq0QMzdoF1eV3LAjPxXwF"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "2sUmY+Ha6IMmVjxKbSJtW2OGKMov9B+MwoDYeSnbFzf1gDg/yjcJCH+dvIWyDkilhh5NHkmnSYsJsnsJd9VGCA=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "pnKH8mHLJX8viKdPUNWKWUQjwaWXzQGOg21KAsx/JdA=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "cgTzL4KyeyeiMFcuCJjF4R2kx59C+J8fU2X8sg6x2wk=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "LIYzeGzjZreBMT3I",
              "ciphertext": "5sryabG6UB1TCpQN2+0rcwe6x7ZK5xdbbuynIkZ751aa32KLEA==",
              "authorSignature": "DhQ0nDmixHBmJA7hhn7IWuI/fzQkxQaxb0CEEAwf2VAKgbG7+pC9XpH6X5VadRne/RRCluHdUzd7PXl/Lgu6BA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Gp96DQ/ibC6g6GcfcU3OrRXnmAJdKrrEhHFjmWYE4F0=",
            "parents": [
              "pnKH8mHLJX8viKdPUNWKWUQjwaWXzQGOg21KAsx/JdA="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "cgTzL4KyeyeiMFcuCJjF4R2kx59C+J8fU2X8sg6x2wk=",
            "keyEpoch": 1,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "m8vbT2FUQv67FFi2",
            "ciphertext": "PAQ9g1YkBJgV0fIbGRUARJvKkv7DtZTOcr9ARUFyGcq/oA9fpQ==",
            "authorSignature": "x00tkkishOtL0ZH11K1hYMhnVuxRRWzozibal305/SBU4rcxXWfayV90jo/JBYjJcIWsesAOeVQSBo3R9527AQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "W3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "EKVqlKhdLhYEvZQL5wTJPLgmYhVYDFWpjjJ28kjMEyI=",
                      "iv": "iSkxgnL3kgaEk67v",
                      "ciphertext": "v+ohC6/qTYbKgENbiZvh1dYBzEULt05k+cHVcub+SX1s5cdXWNenQ/4hfbqPhHN6"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "W+eDD8GzHQP5hPPZaIwXF2uEP3fSeM6KG5hv3W1ZSErbEgk/hi1CdH2KhAGkFkF1tpFT+WIws26himRKZvUMAw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a3-child-of-a1-cites-W3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "DEjVkDI9Qdom/J0+GSFoFZnZvYdRNjlJaiIqEUJdQKw=",
            "parents": [
              "Gp96DQ/ibC6g6GcfcU3OrRXnmAJdKrrEhHFjmWYE4F0="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "S+mnzjzWKXg007s6Ah+zrlxaWDGMZvYw9q0WcTnMWFo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "eGMT4La2zohuDN58",
            "ciphertext": "zXujzJRUswOG1mRut9+zVAljrfqovTpNmdj57koI4lyu9+oRPg==",
            "authorSignature": "qRxL8rLQyT/AY9w33t8VCUAjGKMUGu8REYC5muKdDlpDcGXmylEo8KSeiH7kmPlhKYDgRnDDFJE5d+jaQ67kCQ=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [
        "DEjVkDI9Qdom/J0+GSFoFZnZvYdRNjlJaiIqEUJdQKw=",
        "Gp96DQ/ibC6g6GcfcU3OrRXnmAJdKrrEhHFjmWYE4F0=",
        "pnKH8mHLJX8viKdPUNWKWUQjwaWXzQGOg21KAsx/JdA="
      ],
      "finalTip": "S+mnzjzWKXg007s6Ah+zrlxaWDGMZvYw9q0WcTnMWFo="
    },
    {
      "name": "losing-rotation-commit-kept-held",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5, 8.3: holding W3 (removes bob, epoch 1), the host is offered the losing L3 (removes carol, epoch 1, higher hash) with its rotation commit: L3 loses (manifest_conflict) and is retained, and its rotation commit is kept with it as a held commit.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "EKVqlKhdLhYEvZQL5wTJPLgmYhVYDFWpjjJ28kjMEyI=",
                      "iv": "iSkxgnL3kgaEk67v",
                      "ciphertext": "v+ohC6/qTYbKgENbiZvh1dYBzEULt05k+cHVcub+SX1s5cdXWNenQ/4hfbqPhHN6"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "a2NMcVIN4PMszExodcdO7Za7FlKkHqe29AGhlXoJ19iiahnVN84vLY55D2k/zGHGWmx74oWB9LvhfBkAEKP+Aw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "W3 + rotW",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zqxSoL2nfxKNdJuzMU9mni383tEKqyulVn0nuEmPvJY=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "bNJl6+PMz54/w/tY6YNQvfmVq1pDki1Zz523KJHrX2g=",
                      "iv": "XoTW3J/jyI7M23h9",
                      "ciphertext": "67dH1gICrs0sodRuSMJkLIize1clc4cP8SbcDqsH+LgDxXwVKWnW8LDtrlrHx7oA"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "rs24rduUb75diRRfieJDCwDEWp0/ZcmsuXaHDJlCs6/yujytZIYvMApalf+Vw+eK4jXj7ZXhZTK1UtephFruBg=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "evEP5sVo2bva0v8oNmKYUAFw8NhTSswKMnBcxfnqMjI=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "299BePT8Xv22MSRYpvkAqjKwRIxQmdUIAcwuViDVCZA=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "klMpNB0nzkooX9Tz",
              "ciphertext": "w8urxQtwbcTnER1tv9FUG/wKrE0fof4S21nb7xQOyHQsulAA4w==",
              "authorSignature": "zLDOT30HWfgkf/LCx7L5/9DahIgK7HtkfuifqMRj9PfSwMyELxrZ7DWQRh+QrngiqyXlWZ4axz563qngaStuCw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "L3 + rotL-removes-carol",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zqxSoL2nfxKNdJuzMU9mni383tEKqyulVn0nuEmPvJY=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "+h+iPg3AC9z+5eCT/F8AUfSDf8fIy/pL6DX79PBdDRY=",
                      "iv": "6wxj5toVGYh6CL1i",
                      "ciphertext": "JrHOSC7f4JTCKU2aSavC3Uziat1dsOlVeMRRqBjpD1iZMlqLJyPISXhZbXpzJ7GP"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "izycWH1zKp3YobfGGh1ctmaZJYfbNw/6rPNZl159eBk=",
                      "iv": "XuQgVibEHrgIXhVZ",
                      "ciphertext": "w4n3k/p9/R3R50nx/vvIVlNSjRItT7mr0i3dOeSptqisuzEoBApWhy3+uJxMsjQ9"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "pHn3uTVEW/GWYIBXvXAtH64oDJPqybWtWYkzPIDjYFk=",
                      "iv": "j2UGwX4ILqzBoPDK",
                      "ciphertext": "sjGEUemmua2HqCygksq5y1Poec6rxR+Gk9OqjzvijOkiq0QMzdoF1eV3LAjPxXwF"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "AZZElfRbqCoCFY7k5rVW5SxTG1fPqjqOKZCGqh1mUv0nJU8r43B8+U7V08IbrAjyfsU5/o+JbHUtdNeUTzlpAA=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "iCFJ0lu2a4Yu7C4DdIhSZ3TXMtMZsFeRV+WOOy/dCMU=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "/cbU+MZRiAVaLfJk7bfZ/KmxYsYBHojASvyf0kddh9A=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "/UR69guIJRyoItBE",
              "ciphertext": "Cx2A0hfu4am4Aef77XZ2FRlseRVLNhLfddQ3Dy2dwr2ptkzUVw==",
              "authorSignature": "ZXCF1uZ/Vftcuq81SkExcxWkk3gbizxhPTLupbp+EWiU9rw0HMxbgaGynk9Ij+kOpq65e5WeuHAsoE+qCFOGAA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "manifest_conflict"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "evEP5sVo2bva0v8oNmKYUAFw8NhTSswKMnBcxfnqMjI="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [
        "iCFJ0lu2a4Yu7C4DdIhSZ3TXMtMZsFeRV+WOOy/dCMU="
      ],
      "finalTip": "299BePT8Xv22MSRYpvkAqjKwRIxQmdUIAcwuViDVCZA="
    },
    {
      "name": "losing-commit-failing-cutoff-rejected",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5 (1), 7.3: bob's b1 cites the retained losing L3 at epoch 1. The removal cutoff takes precedence: bob is removed in the tip W3 with frontier {root} and b1 is neither in it nor an ancestor of it, so b1 is rejected (forbidden), never held.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "EKVqlKhdLhYEvZQL5wTJPLgmYhVYDFWpjjJ28kjMEyI=",
                      "iv": "iSkxgnL3kgaEk67v",
                      "ciphertext": "v+ohC6/qTYbKgENbiZvh1dYBzEULt05k+cHVcub+SX1s5cdXWNenQ/4hfbqPhHN6"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "a2NMcVIN4PMszExodcdO7Za7FlKkHqe29AGhlXoJ19iiahnVN84vLY55D2k/zGHGWmx74oWB9LvhfBkAEKP+Aw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "W3 + rotW",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zqxSoL2nfxKNdJuzMU9mni383tEKqyulVn0nuEmPvJY=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "bNJl6+PMz54/w/tY6YNQvfmVq1pDki1Zz523KJHrX2g=",
                      "iv": "XoTW3J/jyI7M23h9",
                      "ciphertext": "67dH1gICrs0sodRuSMJkLIize1clc4cP8SbcDqsH+LgDxXwVKWnW8LDtrlrHx7oA"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "rs24rduUb75diRRfieJDCwDEWp0/ZcmsuXaHDJlCs6/yujytZIYvMApalf+Vw+eK4jXj7ZXhZTK1UtephFruBg=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "evEP5sVo2bva0v8oNmKYUAFw8NhTSswKMnBcxfnqMjI=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "299BePT8Xv22MSRYpvkAqjKwRIxQmdUIAcwuViDVCZA=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "klMpNB0nzkooX9Tz",
              "ciphertext": "w8urxQtwbcTnER1tv9FUG/wKrE0fof4S21nb7xQOyHQsulAA4w==",
              "authorSignature": "zLDOT30HWfgkf/LCx7L5/9DahIgK7HtkfuifqMRj9PfSwMyELxrZ7DWQRh+QrngiqyXlWZ4axz563qngaStuCw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "L3 + rotL-removes-carol",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zqxSoL2nfxKNdJuzMU9mni383tEKqyulVn0nuEmPvJY=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "+h+iPg3AC9z+5eCT/F8AUfSDf8fIy/pL6DX79PBdDRY=",
                      "iv": "6wxj5toVGYh6CL1i",
                      "ciphertext": "JrHOSC7f4JTCKU2aSavC3Uziat1dsOlVeMRRqBjpD1iZMlqLJyPISXhZbXpzJ7GP"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "izycWH1zKp3YobfGGh1ctmaZJYfbNw/6rPNZl159eBk=",
                      "iv": "XuQgVibEHrgIXhVZ",
                      "ciphertext": "w4n3k/p9/R3R50nx/vvIVlNSjRItT7mr0i3dOeSptqisuzEoBApWhy3+uJxMsjQ9"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "pHn3uTVEW/GWYIBXvXAtH64oDJPqybWtWYkzPIDjYFk=",
                      "iv": "j2UGwX4ILqzBoPDK",
                      "ciphertext": "sjGEUemmua2HqCygksq5y1Poec6rxR+Gk9OqjzvijOkiq0QMzdoF1eV3LAjPxXwF"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "AZZElfRbqCoCFY7k5rVW5SxTG1fPqjqOKZCGqh1mUv0nJU8r43B8+U7V08IbrAjyfsU5/o+JbHUtdNeUTzlpAA=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "iCFJ0lu2a4Yu7C4DdIhSZ3TXMtMZsFeRV+WOOy/dCMU=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "/cbU+MZRiAVaLfJk7bfZ/KmxYsYBHojASvyf0kddh9A=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "/UR69guIJRyoItBE",
              "ciphertext": "Cx2A0hfu4am4Aef77XZ2FRlseRVLNhLfddQ3Dy2dwr2ptkzUVw==",
              "authorSignature": "ZXCF1uZ/Vftcuq81SkExcxWkk3gbizxhPTLupbp+EWiU9rw0HMxbgaGynk9Ij+kOpq65e5WeuHAsoE+qCFOGAA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "manifest_conflict"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "b1-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "5pSs+IRLCAFtDtqzT+CpxUca8IBDlSXANJe6X8zMXBo=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "/cbU+MZRiAVaLfJk7bfZ/KmxYsYBHojASvyf0kddh9A=",
            "keyEpoch": 1,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "1K9UKoiNEgpkdmCA",
            "ciphertext": "b4GbgFCBwRr/D4u5Oa/pqug8Jni/cX+oAcnT6wmePXe6OOb6jA==",
            "authorSignature": "koQkQr7QY1bNAfdviv4eEC8JDKLrWjWiPUccXtGxjVAEVSDsdqQw3/48+BAg4edLPWqQjfHEZeTLYIeGDKBYDw=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "evEP5sVo2bva0v8oNmKYUAFw8NhTSswKMnBcxfnqMjI="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [
        "iCFJ0lu2a4Yu7C4DdIhSZ3TXMtMZsFeRV+WOOy/dCMU="
      ],
      "finalTip": "299BePT8Xv22MSRYpvkAqjKwRIxQmdUIAcwuViDVCZA="
    },
    {
      "name": "held-commit-dropped-on-author-removal",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5 drop test, 7.3: rotL and alice's a1 are held once W3 wins. W4 removes alice (epoch 1) with frontier {root}: a1 is not covered, so it is dropped. rotL meets no drop test and W4 lists the owner at its epoch 1, so it is accepted beside W4's rotation commit.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "L3 + rotL",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "+h+iPg3AC9z+5eCT/F8AUfSDf8fIy/pL6DX79PBdDRY=",
                      "iv": "6wxj5toVGYh6CL1i",
                      "ciphertext": "JrHOSC7f4JTCKU2aSavC3Uziat1dsOlVeMRRqBjpD1iZMlqLJyPISXhZbXpzJ7GP"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "pHn3uTVEW/GWYIBXvXAtH64oDJPqybWtWYkzPIDjYFk=",
                      "iv": "j2UGwX4ILqzBoPDK",
                      "ciphertext": "sjGEUemmua2HqCygksq5y1Poec6rxR+Gk9OqjzvijOkiq0QMzdoF1eV3LAjPxXwF"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "2sUmY+Ha6IMmVjxKbSJtW2OGKMov9B+MwoDYeSnbFzf1gDg/yjcJCH+dvIWyDkilhh5NHkmnSYsJsnsJd9VGCA=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "pnKH8mHLJX8viKdPUNWKWUQjwaWXzQGOg21KAsx/JdA=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "cgTzL4KyeyeiMFcuCJjF4R2kx59C+J8fU2X8sg6x2wk=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "LIYzeGzjZreBMT3I",
              "ciphertext": "5sryabG6UB1TCpQN2+0rcwe6x7ZK5xdbbuynIkZ751aa32KLEA==",
              "authorSignature": "DhQ0nDmixHBmJA7hhn7IWuI/fzQkxQaxb0CEEAwf2VAKgbG7+pC9XpH6X5VadRne/RRCluHdUzd7PXl/Lgu6BA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "Gp96DQ/ibC6g6GcfcU3OrRXnmAJdKrrEhHFjmWYE4F0=",
            "parents": [
              "pnKH8mHLJX8viKdPUNWKWUQjwaWXzQGOg21KAsx/JdA="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "cgTzL4KyeyeiMFcuCJjF4R2kx59C+J8fU2X8sg6x2wk=",
            "keyEpoch": 1,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "m8vbT2FUQv67FFi2",
            "ciphertext": "PAQ9g1YkBJgV0fIbGRUARJvKkv7DtZTOcr9ARUFyGcq/oA9fpQ==",
            "authorSignature": "x00tkkishOtL0ZH11K1hYMhnVuxRRWzozibal305/SBU4rcxXWfayV90jo/JBYjJcIWsesAOeVQSBo3R9527AQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "W3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "EKVqlKhdLhYEvZQL5wTJPLgmYhVYDFWpjjJ28kjMEyI=",
                      "iv": "iSkxgnL3kgaEk67v",
                      "ciphertext": "v+ohC6/qTYbKgENbiZvh1dYBzEULt05k+cHVcub+SX1s5cdXWNenQ/4hfbqPhHN6"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "W+eDD8GzHQP5hPPZaIwXF2uEP3fSeM6KG5hv3W1ZSErbEgk/hi1CdH2KhAGkFkF1tpFT+WIws26himRKZvUMAw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "W4 + rot4",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 4,
                "prevManifestHash": "S+mnzjzWKXg007s6Ah+zrlxaWDGMZvYw9q0WcTnMWFo=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "ccNbfofkQR5alrMgURlEK0sIahoecor46Mwvb5ui2z8=",
                      "iv": "aQF3rMEMaCbn+0L+",
                      "ciphertext": "K3i2w5EAs3pZyfcAS41VJdA5+d74LhH23Q6DiGSDA3ROEklfbTsnYTL7iDNyVUs4"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "bNJl6+PMz54/w/tY6YNQvfmVq1pDki1Zz523KJHrX2g=",
                      "iv": "XoTW3J/jyI7M23h9",
                      "ciphertext": "67dH1gICrs0sodRuSMJkLIize1clc4cP8SbcDqsH+LgDxXwVKWnW8LDtrlrHx7oA"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 4,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "aag2rVE8kvaaRDlFPkg/bM2DBtSiyvr+vJTCxC/wSJpjzl5NdVqLfPrB1jf4Fk+0MopvPUfXszvSkZY1wkJVCw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "u4KAKgJZbSvbtv7g/3Q6RDJJ438VhtneS2TbHk+1kt8=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 4,
              "manifestHash": "l9oh5HCKA5EQ4IntegLGzDEErMR/MISW6xREHAuFP2Y=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "/aNvpPkr2Zd12ksR",
              "ciphertext": "NGYDpRR44MQ9yCiaUSbav4eEyu6Rvim4Fo0RadvAyqCMNhVYHw==",
              "authorSignature": "ut7/oVc9hLpkoVMASGvhCJO1fhf86gB5vO74DrVSZjy2zKkHQ661LSHsVRmZDkZQxuidBUEEXDkvSbEuQ42vCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "pnKH8mHLJX8viKdPUNWKWUQjwaWXzQGOg21KAsx/JdA=",
        "u4KAKgJZbSvbtv7g/3Q6RDJJ438VhtneS2TbHk+1kt8="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "l9oh5HCKA5EQ4IntegLGzDEErMR/MISW6xREHAuFP2Y="
    },
    {
      "name": "chain-switch-drops-by-cutoff",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5, 7.3: the host holds H3 (adds carol) and accepts bob's b1 citing it. W3 (removes bob, epoch 1, frontier {root}, lower hash) then wins with its rotation commit. Re-checking b1 against the winning chain, the removal cutoff takes precedence and b1 fails it: dropped; the rotation commit is the only head.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "H3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "6Dako6l4BedkwH9VVp6krUZF7Sh0DlHJpF3xP5G3a3g=",
                      "iv": "z/CYdocZ0YSf5CQZ",
                      "ciphertext": "Kdi+05q0yoOQvLuic31+Vj1Y+UUy246PI761bB60CMRljuJ/7a3xBXUKiqyNfIoY"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "86m3BLzTCoG0ggSAi5ADxZHqPRR0goMLZDH6WuHGoVU=",
                      "iv": "yWvr3fss/pTd71h8",
                      "ciphertext": "g+GLlLbO7jzuJnbls5KB5HkqwrcmK5lkB8pg0i+7Qkrj9aQ5u+anfvmWd0GwkbEt"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "w1D/NvmGqWMsoQpCN/TXOXHlQHv8Rz0AMWeAdf3+i04=",
                      "iv": "S17ZGMFh4fhu6SC0",
                      "ciphertext": "0kAgA/DVhmedlpRbNTsN7WWdx5Iu+Dmcbsps3pjUXeoNhS9OlMEYUgU7MNEfqM2u"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Bn1+aJMMk+hc4fJaaCdI7JnlmxMXMklpnY4JHDSmwBI=",
                      "iv": "uIztAvEEIjdDecM/",
                      "ciphertext": "TSobRVWF60bZSNewEm7BlYDEvZaMiPlLkCwQUSfHTUWk1+NiSp0jNyBblvkoVeS0"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "+tnyUliWnq0EarX2Dfp0+drGxRiFXng1a0nvDjb1U4NFt8LVEEk6SBHah+pNIa11HdduCK1Qq7tclw0WwgoiDw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b1-cites-H3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "ctMLSqXsA/O0tpXlsv4oaQ7e5fBGl0r9cBRcRh7psRU=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "dz8gAcLQgF1G6WKrwhbPM5dmve3LRElet+VYeGTaA78=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "BuO2ffK7h3TLK7JX",
            "ciphertext": "UURfpUmJDniyQ6BaU9PC8YZqcz0O+U301Mb1cdA9wYZYMA8Xdg==",
            "authorSignature": "XZAAKmwRk9j+fZX8gW+BQDUNDxMK5NpWvXuZM9reF48mBKE/xjil+Dzdm5Uf/hOIL6r52ITOXWy8kuBpYxtIDw=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "W3 + rotW",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "aIx2pt4lP3Y3wSWtuzHtCLpsnYVw4XlhgWVPJOc5zuQlny3KVg+Z820IHmJ0iDQvnnYbnQvKtT75xNA2ln4kDw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "1Ah/i0f82SAwd8YDZGMAiKtsfcCp6DScwxkil0B81PU=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "klMpNB0nzkooX9Tz",
              "ciphertext": "w8urxQtwbcTnER1tv9FUG/wKrE0fof4S21nb7xQOyHQsulAA4w==",
              "authorSignature": "We2XQ0XT1T+3hyLSA4a7TY68aSF4fBKzD7iWMj4cS1RND4zNgedRVV0Re5d9Dc29NkJLsXRlGsOG0H2son4IBQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "1Ah/i0f82SAwd8YDZGMAiKtsfcCp6DScwxkil0B81PU="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ="
    },
    {
      "name": "held-descendants-accepted-in-turn",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5: carol's c1 and its child c2 cite the losing L3 and are held when W3 wins. W4 re-invites carol at epoch 0: c1 is accepted, and its held descendant c2 is re-checked in turn and accepted, leaving c2 the only head.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "L3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "6Dako6l4BedkwH9VVp6krUZF7Sh0DlHJpF3xP5G3a3g=",
                      "iv": "z/CYdocZ0YSf5CQZ",
                      "ciphertext": "Kdi+05q0yoOQvLuic31+Vj1Y+UUy246PI761bB60CMRljuJ/7a3xBXUKiqyNfIoY"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "w1D/NvmGqWMsoQpCN/TXOXHlQHv8Rz0AMWeAdf3+i04=",
                      "iv": "S17ZGMFh4fhu6SC0",
                      "ciphertext": "0kAgA/DVhmedlpRbNTsN7WWdx5Iu+Dmcbsps3pjUXeoNhS9OlMEYUgU7MNEfqM2u"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Bn1+aJMMk+hc4fJaaCdI7JnlmxMXMklpnY4JHDSmwBI=",
                      "iv": "uIztAvEEIjdDecM/",
                      "ciphertext": "TSobRVWF60bZSNewEm7BlYDEvZaMiPlLkCwQUSfHTUWk1+NiSp0jNyBblvkoVeS0"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "6xRCwdFvn6Ed5oq3UEMkWiTCbdM1n/IN5ccM82EElrz8eDng5mvMC8IFD8fcF7Xd/00n2nXCqRB1EgFTzEwtCQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "c1-cites-L3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "BZn8QrkkGjasN1RV2dSltm8DZx8kgTjruMKja8e1RJo=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "7tAgalMoajsi3mxX2WhDyFv2IKU5Sp+TuF6dXVhjdYg=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "iv": "WoLtWqoVAbwp4zN3",
            "ciphertext": "aLZWxXQcAKdrklyOP/aAfk8/lq4HfqBpraAFjifjGQ7/BcLLFQ==",
            "authorSignature": "YJJVuiUfN4K9SJMHrQnnJsfAHBiat/cF4kczrOtC6dDQQySkwGpiLRN6Ke9ZNXWTg5/mkiW+F0xcN02b5W3dCA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "c2-child-of-c1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "O2BC+AeUzdX5slSI++1j0OoKL6ZsDOgJITWp7GQF1ag=",
            "parents": [
              "BZn8QrkkGjasN1RV2dSltm8DZx8kgTjruMKja8e1RJo="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "7tAgalMoajsi3mxX2WhDyFv2IKU5Sp+TuF6dXVhjdYg=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
            "iv": "4hh0nE6IEHt2X8X0",
            "ciphertext": "2FY5ZD99uTvP4sEJ6uFrflhbvZzeVRVEcyIV/ZvkAz64ExNA4g==",
            "authorSignature": "Ddnb/e9mSNyr7HDgLuyNwF798h30z0U2ijzstlp4UG4JMHw2bHOQoXUwwss+3hgF54p7k5o10QoftY3h647dBQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "W3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": true,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Mn4ZU3ZwKleT/zz3pz8nIeSPbvYygX6vsra4+kw8gZ/YNh4mlCpylQI3wV1RXdOot+PBL2nXGSkWbDET4yY0Bg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "W4",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 4,
                "prevManifestHash": "y+VhzDkFs+Ij085ZYnW2ZHGd5cC5aDmtcZuu6M+hxHI=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": true,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "EKVqlKhdLhYEvZQL5wTJPLgmYhVYDFWpjjJ28kjMEyI=",
                      "iv": "iSkxgnL3kgaEk67v",
                      "ciphertext": "v+ohC6/qTYbKgENbiZvh1dYBzEULt05k+cHVcub+SX1s5cdXWNenQ/4hfbqPhHN6"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "9wxcwJPE/qukmX1uVSN/sFSHbx9rO3XQEgIc8SiZb1ULyGsIbHtObMooFi3uXkJu5fE3F0ACsXHh1+VA+/YYCg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "O2BC+AeUzdX5slSI++1j0OoKL6ZsDOgJITWp7GQF1ag="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "NwgHYqSf8uEKHkkUX/4fRchyRYKROaFDPtqsiYBjClk="
    },
    {
      "name": "leave-dropped-on-removal",
      "description": "SPEC 8.4: the host keeps bob's and alice's leave requests and drops bob's once a state removes bob; alice's stays pending.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "leave",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "bob-leave",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "at": 1767229200000,
            "signature": "nwJvP6SDkpD32z1FwRFmaZvfyn0gen5fB82iGETTM7a3qTFo3WcE7j7ChEkcm+mF+hqfrvAMIFs9YOdKYmIoBA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "leave",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "alice-leave",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "memberKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "at": 1767229200000,
            "signature": "GRAXN/+3DMbFRA+cW4nj8Uwp4kZR0+EnT4QJgGsMkLoryog3dZbjo3QJ9olbWYXsvV8b1yaunk1uAfMT3D6nAg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M3 + rot",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "RvGev9s9Abzs5Oj2v6qwNacj8ABz85obV3stdZxuoyE=",
                      "iv": "pyltSS3q8IIamIYQ",
                      "ciphertext": "RPYhShHcNwd5iDF91Ub205vddW4UMLYFZvAyeGlI+LN68cgE2wcT+t8jnwKEyEKb"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "aIx2pt4lP3Y3wSWtuzHtCLpsnYVw4XlhgWVPJOc5zuQlny3KVg+Z820IHmJ0iDQvnnYbnQvKtT75xNA2ln4kDw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "UidzS/j8L2ZLh8v5foloSNlUfZz1+WIJyol1XOC90zQ=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JvWulNZs5gpJXSS2",
              "ciphertext": "lU6AXvJAJkg/57Xwx9EUmrZFegP9QwcgW6+5QdoGVGBf1vS2Nw==",
              "authorSignature": "bOJu/Ika0LN+9gKXPvxHU3COk2Nmp44hSnzPH7Dmj4jiafOjcKVbPxr6Nism4k6O0dSM+qxaqob7mGaZv0L0Bw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "UidzS/j8L2ZLh8v5foloSNlUfZz1+WIJyol1XOC90zQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "WwquvBlnV+YD1JYG2jDf94aR92pxvtQB+AUoQr93tiQ=",
      "finalLeaves": [
        {
          "memberKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
          "at": 1767229200000
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "name": "leave-latest-per-member",
      "description": "SPEC 8.4: the host keeps the latest leave request per member; alice sends one and then a later one, and only the later one is pending.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "leave",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "alice-leave",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "memberKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "at": 1767229200000,
            "signature": "GRAXN/+3DMbFRA+cW4nj8Uwp4kZR0+EnT4QJgGsMkLoryog3dZbjo3QJ9olbWYXsvV8b1yaunk1uAfMT3D6nAg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "leave",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "alice-leave-later",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "memberKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "at": 1767229201000,
            "signature": "7apSVPl19CrRMScVz2mU6oxM74PPFAAbPeJrzhfaPOTocKxEXSi2Xk3UhibrXuQwzkBPxBurP4dr2CxsGnawDQ=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo=",
      "finalLeaves": [
        {
          "memberKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
          "at": 1767229201000
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "name": "pending-losing-commit-rechecked-when-decided",
      "description": "SPEC 6.5, 7.3, 7.4: the host holds H3 (adds carol, epoch 0) and accepts bob's b1 citing it. W3 (removes bob at epoch 1 with frontier {x}, lower hash) then wins; x, bob's child of b1, is unknown, so b1's cutoff is undecided and b1 MUST NOT stay accepted. When x arrives its header decides the cutoff (b1 is an ancestor of x), and b1, which cites a losing state, is re-checked by SPEC 6.5: W3 does not list bob, and the drop test holds (tip epoch 1 exceeds b1's 0), so b1 is dropped. x's parent is then rejected: forbidden. The rotation commit is the only head.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "H3",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "F8t5+ytBIPKx7GXkGY1uCLKOgT/rAeSkAIObheGAgM4=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "ew1H2TQn+DERYHgcfHM/2J+IlwrvSQ2KoO4ZpMuKGxQ=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "EKVqlKhdLhYEvZQL5wTJPLgmYhVYDFWpjjJ28kjMEyI=",
                      "iv": "iSkxgnL3kgaEk67v",
                      "ciphertext": "v+ohC6/qTYbKgENbiZvh1dYBzEULt05k+cHVcub+SX1s5cdXWNenQ/4hfbqPhHN6"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "W+eDD8GzHQP5hPPZaIwXF2uEP3fSeM6KG5hv3W1ZSErbEgk/hi1CdH2KhAGkFkF1tpFT+WIws26himRKZvUMAw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b1-cites-H3",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "1UQWQwl0iM8JBDkphtCPlsgfQUFK7fK5dlilG3E/Dwc=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 3,
            "manifestHash": "S+mnzjzWKXg007s6Ah+zrlxaWDGMZvYw9q0WcTnMWFo=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "BuO2ffK7h3TLK7JX",
            "ciphertext": "UURfpUmJDniyQ6BaU9PC8YZqcz0O+U301Mb1cdA9wYZYMA8Xdg==",
            "authorSignature": "Pb+HTXqFqoz3F41mJuBsA5U1zHyYM/9ZgVHW8CSJmdJGVhePR1yJUMKORQPIHWdYI1P9A7aF4QYZliZ6qm8wBg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "W3 + rotW",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "+h+iPg3AC9z+5eCT/F8AUfSDf8fIy/pL6DX79PBdDRY=",
                      "iv": "6wxj5toVGYh6CL1i",
                      "ciphertext": "JrHOSC7f4JTCKU2aSavC3Uziat1dsOlVeMRRqBjpD1iZMlqLJyPISXhZbXpzJ7GP"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "pHn3uTVEW/GWYIBXvXAtH64oDJPqybWtWYkzPIDjYFk=",
                      "iv": "j2UGwX4ILqzBoPDK",
                      "ciphertext": "sjGEUemmua2HqCygksq5y1Poec6rxR+Gk9OqjzvijOkiq0QMzdoF1eV3LAjPxXwF"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "l9qRr8/gkIplQeqrKKQMdvGTop7mQupXc0j4Agj8lTw="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "3RWJpRkh2pzWiehd2RRPIhe4nYb1X+ldBcT487cB/F02a31/7scz2IaYN4CiMwHwf2vsiA9ILT8HkT1TY66mAg=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "KgM0XlK4Y0SYK1xp2yYXG4gO/1u9jInTDnePwpHwrDk=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "Ipn0FXzGF73XwC51V+TgjLDk4tassBUfKM6f0Ps02Iw=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "klMpNB0nzkooX9Tz",
              "ciphertext": "w8urxQtwbcTnER1tv9FUG/wKrE0fof4S21nb7xQOyHQsulAA4w==",
              "authorSignature": "xrmio6j1zVkJSOLRXPfghhWKe08b+BUje8EJywCR9qtfezTTb0mQUoLkBgBiiniHxtxOnAZ322rpGDIAw8KBCw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "x-child-of-b1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "l9qRr8/gkIplQeqrKKQMdvGTop7mQupXc0j4Agj8lTw=",
            "parents": [
              "1UQWQwl0iM8JBDkphtCPlsgfQUFK7fK5dlilG3E/Dwc="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "DwHR9O4EpaUeGcwG",
            "ciphertext": "vKuULU8SfEP5clooxVqMJ1pgAbJ8WrT7jFiMze3UQyeilPknwA==",
            "authorSignature": "KBY7uT3L++S+haPbhLjReUTg9i1Unb2HpQN37KeXKstnoY+ZjMxsX6tROSwGMxFflcmr7G+sGjxPCO2aJSGbAw=="
          },
          "expect": "forbidden"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "KgM0XlK4Y0SYK1xp2yYXG4gO/1u9jInTDnePwpHwrDk="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "Ipn0FXzGF73XwC51V+TgjLDk4tassBUfKM6f0Ps02Iw="
    },
    {
      "name": "stale-publish-with-content-violation",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 (the host answers with the first failure, in rule order), 6.3: while the tip is seq 2, a client publishes another seq 2 state on genesis that also lists no host. Rule 4 (chain link: a client state MUST be at tip + 1) fails before rule 5 (content), so the answer is manifest_conflict, not bad_request.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Tb24Qr7aXdYfutCujNcwvYwywK7tRictX0rf0JDqjutOICsd5+g5kxiw36oKQTifyTaVJVF1nqvKlAvLt39OCA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2-stale-no-hosts",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "QkYIzRxBEMepP32Y/R4uIL3u20iHzsg8uVhxQAq6oGHrFgM46+qs2xmCP2SWuVlvZEboY9N7PgaupUNM8YAfAA=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "manifest_conflict"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "zREx/aJEK8676G8oLtDqXtR4TVjkOjcECUXOED0WvNo="
    },
    {
      "name": "pending-commit-resolved-by-losing-rotation-header",
      "description": "SPEC 7.3, 6.5, 8.3: bob's b1 (citing seq 2) is accepted. W3 removes bob at epoch 1 with frontier {rotL}; rotL is unknown here, so b1's cutoff cannot be decided and b1 MUST NOT stay accepted. L3 (removes alice, epoch 1, higher hash) then arrives with its rotation commit rotL, whose parent is b1: L3 loses the tie rule (manifest_conflict) and rotL is kept held with it (SPEC 8.3). Ancestry for the cutoff follows every verified header whether or not accepted (SPEC 7.3), so b1 is an ancestor of frontier commit rotL; covered, and citing the winning seq 2 where bob is a member at epoch 0, b1 is accepted again.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "G + r",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "hjgiGvZ5ZHMuHjAXE4qIzNeCNOV5W4acZRfUfdgzHdo5uM0NiQFgsZBESiBlzj5JlgXmcl4zu3MUEUTViiOUBQ=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "FlDSpXDo5Rb94glU",
              "ciphertext": "QyVLRkYTSMlxfXaeW812B7g7W3SUR8snSas5KKUAr2TWte0cjw==",
              "authorSignature": "+WEUCDSWH6PDrSC5kP9zTPg6SR0HIcSv7ksFSwwg8ezi+qz9V+16g7ZDA1kaE7zK8RB0NGcLiJ67+xVEkD3WAg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "M2",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "U97TJ+GGCQDS2nAOVEshg1bFnJ8uF1OlQD7B6O0lRC0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "eLq0CnxPtlspJcf3ClZe4iamK0eGwwGqUTXr27h8TAI=",
                      "iv": "fXranwaadGrx5ubH",
                      "ciphertext": "Qnf/92XkCu9K7GSctiaDB6u+HC0o2GBQC9VHCYR8JykhmCDpi7YDDgcA6bZHje69"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "4i8qfN5JJP6OobTLPw5lQAbn74DyPEDBgusQLaNtkwqNaDUjlNb9qDqKuJHA9++np9aRxNEnK4+LDHeTRX23BQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "b1",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
            "parents": [
              "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
            "iv": "ja7DPQSFiSKcH8/P",
            "ciphertext": "LCwZLe1snwQHUL00n9nTotPVnv4uv5wI4NrxeswHPKDMlBSTqg==",
            "authorSignature": "ZSzcMthK/wLlICIQskYQusscst9+emsKrMGQtg6SFhBPMkap5ud1e33eyDzSNLmxT05LhbNSK4n38wgJrUobCg=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "W3 + rotW",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "KEep4jUpTk0lz5h2x/svEoUyBxzU8kH+pwN6r3RL/j0=",
                      "iv": "VdkZk0zVTtNTWP4Z",
                      "ciphertext": "+TCiS8/14gljhsWCNelm6vm5gC9mb4X5xc0aWoB/VgJAa2rX7SDk7/uDEa7Zud6K"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "xkuSHrNeVyKn0ErRQuAe3CYtbcF7hx5YHqDqJjfzOzk=",
                      "iv": "+R/WoVsIObZH4xtL",
                      "ciphertext": "W2nAlhajR50PcyIevlZgi2BhFYtA4nxBVgxUw1ym6ADSv7TQpFBo4daGuiq+BuIE"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "oz8um6uzLB2Ueyg2LGlyfcIZa1qz+I8+//mu9z0dBY4="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "NlAoVAXxgXsy0eCrnAfJ67yI8QZqLdNQVXbON6aKvBwaayJlOs7Tzaln4nGJXAyIQWiXsdc3hVg9MfclgdWiCw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "ydaw1CQI6/spVe7Np1P/vn9kY88Dxt+DeKaV3KWreoA=",
              "parents": [
                "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "GN4YLctuEgALdkcWi5prCcXFS7Gaum0Z66h3Z7nvwi0=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "klMpNB0nzkooX9Tz",
              "ciphertext": "w8urxQtwbcTnER1tv9FUG/wKrE0fof4S21nb7xQOyHQsulAA4w==",
              "authorSignature": "83Tkg4InsntzqEApLnMwplmf2Gj26w+A5nZpHnPVn48A+cM/ZPwAlwYwKyyTbhzU77EEZ6Ln2nMMMv3jo7W+Bw=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "L3 + rotL-child-of-b1",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 3,
                "prevManifestHash": "8I4G3cnfIKGI5AlDxjtP3yPAoGjcO9bNSh2uJvjFAp0=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 1,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "oJql9HpnWYAv+VX43C0qFKXJnSO+l/hkEn/5ODRVpPA=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "D6poTtKIZ7l/Smot7l34zpdOdrcBjj8iocTPJnhXDyA=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "ccNbfofkQR5alrMgURlEK0sIahoecor46Mwvb5ui2z8=",
                      "iv": "aQF3rMEMaCbn+0L+",
                      "ciphertext": "K3i2w5EAs3pZyfcAS41VJdA5+d74LhH23Q6DiGSDA3ROEklfbTsnYTL7iDNyVUs4"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "n/5jx5SliiVo31Q2xC54NxU9CMzV5+vDDLaCv3BcqQQ=",
                      "iv": "BwDwaJ9MESog08zN",
                      "ciphertext": "fjtjZGCJVMePLuJS9oZlX0u3LNElIPx0wrsiFreiTTGMSxViFMiEbxfr9kOQ2SWj"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 1,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": [
                  {
                    "memberKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "removedAtSeq": 3,
                    "frontier": [
                      "8p+x5mLKHKNJB79WlNpSYYhZ2sfgigbezHo7nsDcLrQ="
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              },
              "ownerSignature": "nDFsXXlE1hjqRHFgXgGVGkjCu6+ysxT9QmuKnHsGHs/vs1Gxe0D7zJ1Oiht2wT7SND2qySYLytLmzOTPwZGqCw=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "oz8um6uzLB2Ueyg2LGlyfcIZa1qz+I8+//mu9z0dBY4=",
              "parents": [
                "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8="
              ],
              "manifestSeq": 3,
              "manifestHash": "G9uxNbjOtp9UQLY6DeaBIJ/WoGKO21eiPRtRIdsSbjw=",
              "keyEpoch": 1,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "hivCoNk1BmRiXc9Z",
              "ciphertext": "EIWqEDqlYVR+uAJa9yEQWZ68y3J2SKfwx1gkmGCKtv8q54tgnw==",
              "authorSignature": "EKeH6epAVkllnAhmX4OF+paYrm0heQ1VKOnEVEFw7ZX1X+sZzsDGDWHABr/BYmEemLiN5qjFRqWyim3ISLKVCg=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "manifest_conflict"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "rtdizBE8P8I2ZiG9V1trtZ1xmbxe6OZNwzlA42xfZP8=",
        "ydaw1CQI6/spVe7Np1P/vn9kY88Dxt+DeKaV3KWreoA="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [
        "oz8um6uzLB2Ueyg2LGlyfcIZa1qz+I8+//mu9z0dBY4="
      ],
      "finalTip": "GN4YLctuEgALdkcWi5prCcXFS7Gaum0Z66h3Z7nvwi0="
    },
    {
      "name": "new-host-first-copy-by-offer",
      "description": "SPEC 6.1 rule 6, 8.1, 9.2: a.vault.example is first listed at seq 2 and gets its first copy by replication. The genesis, which lists only b.vault.example, arrives by offer with its first commit and is accepted: rule 6 applies to the tip of the chain being received, which is the seq 2 state that lists this host, not to the states before it. The seq 2 state is then accepted by offer, and alice, whose home host is a.vault.example and who is a member of the tip at epoch 0, pushes a child of the first commit: accepted, the only head.",
      "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
      "headBound": 16,
      "steps": [
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "Gb + r-b-first-copy",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 1,
                "prevManifestHash": "",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "AQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQEBAQ==",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "gCQwT0LLSl49JkcR7rXsdNbdkwmMlwov0561fMIsAJKAFpsJ8CU/EeTsmwvUzZ/wRFqhCJMswM7rejU8UkaTCA=="
            },
            "commit": {
              "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
              "commitId": "7Rw/87uRnjQV3hAdda2of4vkS0Q0Q9i02Be87xIpsyA=",
              "parents": [],
              "manifestSeq": 1,
              "manifestHash": "ziM5Qj/BgOrpKo1LEFldup1uro1yK9RPmqgbNlB69W4=",
              "keyEpoch": 0,
              "author": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
              "iv": "JEFB0Kwvhgjl6QmP",
              "ciphertext": "8ZmjQFFtHDKbDfFVuM6OR3pyMLMvL4AywFLVumgZkKl/Bx0QNw==",
              "authorSignature": "Tspf3gxN9x942N1+THMJoIC0nRksOvQ4SfjVfliAihRc4Tcc0pUn6jbZxd0owBkOFqI6XsHfqY1pBbspjhiIAQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "manifest",
          "via": "offer",
          "label": "M2-adds-a",
          "item": {
            "manifest": {
              "state": {
                "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
                "manifestSeq": 2,
                "prevManifestHash": "ziM5Qj/BgOrpKo1LEFldup1uro1yK9RPmqgbNlB69W4=",
                "ownerKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                "genesisNonce": "",
                "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                "keyEpoch": 0,
                "shareRefreshTokens": false,
                "hosts": [
                  {
                    "hostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM=",
                    "locator": "a.vault.example"
                  },
                  {
                    "hostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU=",
                    "locator": "b.vault.example"
                  }
                ],
                "members": [
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "e06Qm75//kTEZaIgA31gjuNYl9Me+XLwf3SJLLD3PxM=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "8nySO+InkhnIB7Ohq9p78jBQ5d151W0qONeD7BXCx0k=",
                      "iv": "Bq00EPtbno8BWK//",
                      "ciphertext": "PidkppOMg+vCL2aSxSqPrG8xVo1NiLMn0XSwmrUAQI7yUmZqlRsIFeFv46/ilb5q"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "tTPYrZ/Pvd4LSBwbM03cPFNBL9YUVk5+Wv0CA2jTgsM="
                  },
                  {
                    "ed25519PublicKey": "PogjYKrkUFnBMtnwITJgD2CutbPvGdwV6TdCzE+HrpI=",
                    "x25519PublicKey": "3iuyX3wXx60kUZI3Z5u5m41UhCpF/gemBiaYsmhAdxo=",
                    "wrappedDataKey": {
                      "schemeId": "X25519-HKDF-SHA256-AESGCM-v1",
                      "ephemeralPublicKey": "Sudch5kXiK23OTesrhK4f2vzdh92HLOEOc5jo4Vv0VQ=",
                      "iv": "hH+5MmwRgd+ibNFb",
                      "ciphertext": "LwLA9Ilx68jX/yQw4SD8Q2hvPRvWU4xoyssWB1nJJnNxsgXojW480GUuHQR4GGLG"
                    },
                    "keyEpoch": 0,
                    "homeHostKey": "cF+6wB9VGYmfQ3vELkAlWumrVL/wDeNDOvfWh9nnGtU="
                  }
                ],
                "removals": []
              },
              "ownerSignature": "Bh2oRWdppONM5hC/yd2QarUla5AFvt41BEMHjEm3WLbZcx4W7ZnUuH1i5VkYrTmzoK4ZgdIYz+aHQmgtMhmlAQ=="
            }
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        },
        {
          "op": "commit",
          "via": "push",
          "label": "a1-first-copy",
          "item": {
            "repoId": "RBhoUI0PUSR7tD5HpFC9lA",
            "commitId": "JXoNWSGylZ3C3qAN4IIi2WuCF7TPECRTe73eOigZYec=",
            "parents": [
              "7Rw/87uRnjQV3hAdda2of4vkS0Q0Q9i02Be87xIpsyA="
            ],
            "manifestSeq": 2,
            "manifestHash": "BmeCGGB6HphxYNS8H3RZ/G9djZdxNxgy1jfgVdpy3rs=",
            "keyEpoch": 0,
            "author": "0EqyMnQrtKs6E2i9RhXk5tAiSrcaAWuvhSCjMsl3hzc=",
            "iv": "YW6sKaOk9/pC6Y+7",
            "ciphertext": "HJYyHKjItEhOM853F/NmzHsxEMNDJJ06BD8NDPZOIuRdDycj9A==",
            "authorSignature": "Fdn9Pb2JY+BUPa7Xqub9vX/sNc6d5OLvi28pSnvbVgN/L3twty1qlcbBflg+PgYZYRttcyjhuuySthY1VHAoCA=="
          },
          "expect": "ok"
        }
      ],
      "finalHeads": [
        "JXoNWSGylZ3C3qAN4IIi2WuCF7TPECRTe73eOigZYec="
      ],
      "finalHeld": [],
      "finalTip": "BmeCGGB6HphxYNS8H3RZ/G9djZdxNxgy1jfgVdpy3rs="
    }
  ]
}
